That seems like very little for Tkachuk

The Isles are not trading Dobson, I know there was another ACGM made by an Isles fan but it is not happening. And I doubt Tkachuk would sign long term with the Isles.

yeah only one of the best young RHD in the league

Dobson is good but is he really only a first round pick less valuable than him. I don’t think so. You don’t see 100 point power forwards with such elite defensive games like Tkachuk in the league

6'4 #1 RHD with elite skating ability are extremely rare. Dobson on his own is worth at least two 1sts and a top prospect, so yes he is only a first round pick less valuable. I don;'t even know If the islanders should do this.

LOL Dobson is not worth nearly that much

Dobson is better than Seth Jones who went for that much

As an Isles fan I wouldn't do this deal. I can also 100% see why fans of other teams would say this is a small price to pay for Tkachuk and he will fetch a better haul. It doesn't matter, the Isles won't be in on him whatsoever.

first of all that was a massive overpay by a terrible Chicago FO, and second of all no he is not

Yes he is, Jones has never been more than a 2nd pair caliber D. Dobson is already a #1 RHD

oh my god you are sippin the koolaid huh

The numbers don’t lie, he would be the 2nd best D on the rangers , there’s no one besides Fox who’s on Dobson’s level
">

How are the rangers relevant here? Look at the number for his defense. He's a good second pairing defensemen sure, but not a #1D yet. He has the potential sure but you are being delusional here

What’s wrong with his defense? A defenseman who puts up 51 pts with a good two way impact is a top pair caliber defenseman