I thought Dumba was a decent idea before you got rid of it!

Robertson is kinda meh now. Was overhyped and isn’t anything very special. We also already have a glut of wingers so no need. Sandin is good but we really don’t have any room for a small LHD.

Leafs can't afford to resign him so that is way way too much for a rental

Rangers offered them Lundkvist, Chytil and a 1st last trade deadline and they declined. I think both of those players are more valauable than Robertson and Sandin with the Sandin vs Lundkvist being a little more arguable as to whos more valuable. It is for one less playoff run though, so Miller coming back for one less run is also less valuable. Depending on how far off the rangers deal was from the canucks pov it could be close. I think the Canucks would be a lot more interested if you switched out either knies for robertson or niemola for sandin or both and at that point might not even need to include the 1st.

Way too much for a one year rental in Miller.

And besides Miller wants to play in the States long term, So he's not going to commit long term with Toronto.

Uh oh you included sandin

Miller's Value is slowly declining not rising, the novelty of at least another year is gone & so is his value ceiling, I doubt the Rangers offer the same they did last year & doubt even more that the Leafs pay this for a guaranteed rental no matter how good that rental is

small???? So you know nothing about Sandin???

He’s 5’11. You’re telling me he is not small?

Robertson is 20 years old and has led the ohl in both goals & points and produced at ppg level in ahl. He is not over hyped. And that’s rich coming from canuckle fans who literally over value every single player or prospect on the west coast. Your team is the definition of average yet everyone from Miller to Hoglander to Quinn is elite, or about to be elite .

Hughes and Miller are elite. Hoglander is going through growing pains but all three are miles better than Robertson lmao. He isn’t even a point per game in the AHL.

Robertson just posted 16/12 in 28 games last year in ahl. Even for canuckle fans, the math is pretty simple, that = ppg. Because we actually have elite superstar players (not canuckle delusional elite players ) and a much better team ( we just finished 21 pts ahead of you in a much, much tougher division), we have let Rob develop in minors - where hoglander should have been last year.
you’ve missed the playoffs 6 of the last 7 yet your prospect pool is still bottom 10
Your goalie looks promising but d-corps is awful, OEL is top 10 worst contract in nhl (Myers honourable mention) , your forwards are literally average in a 32 team league and your best player is about to walk but keep on dreaming … hoglander will save you

Ain’t no way you just defended this trade by saying something completely irrelevant on how the Leafs are a better team 😂. How immature and delusional can you be? No wonder everyone knows Leafs fans are complete duds

Not defending any trade bud; I wouldn’t give up that much for a rental. I’m just pointing out how delusional canuckle fans are - it gets tiring trying to wade through your assertions about how good your thoroughly average players or your ridiculous JT Miller trade requests.
And it does make me feel better to point how much better the leafs are than the canuckles 😎

Tell me the list of teams the Leafs have won a series against in the playoffs in the last 15 years

Hoglander to the rescue

What does Hoglander have anything to do with this trade? Now you’re just being unreasonable ignorant

What you can take shots at leafs, but I can’t take shots at canuckles ?
Leafs are a top 5 team as things stand today; they have 2 superstars + 3 elite offensive players (Willy, jt & reilly) + some good complimentary pieces. So they are in no way forced to make any trade.
Impossible to predict how season unfolds but barring any major surprises…
At the deadline - if Miller is available, I would offer 1st + a prospect (not Robertson, Knies or Tiemela). If retention req’d add a pick for 3rd team. If that’s not enough for canuckles, we target another winger - live Jvr or pavelski, etc. dependent on which teams are in the race of course.
We can also call up Knies.

I only took a shot at the Leafs because you did first

For your trade proposal: a first and a prospect, but no good prospects? You have no good prospects outside those you mentioned. So basically a first and a bad prospect? Yeah sure. How about we give him to you for free? Dubas literally traded a first round pick and a fourth round pick for Nick Foligno. Nick Foligno didn’t put up 99 points the season prior. You’re just delusional if you think you’re getting a star player for barely anything.

Star “rental” player - you seem to keep forgetting to mention that. This is apparently one of the deepest drafts in years, so the 1st alone is valuable. You’re one of the guys that keeps pumping hoglander (who was 2nd round pick and never a top tier prospect)… So there is value in mid level prospects. Leafs have much better farm system than you - lots of decent prospects to pick from - hirvonen, minten, holmberg. But if it doesn’t work out, it doesn’t work out. We’ll be fine and can target a more reasonable winger, if even needed.
But As TDL approaches pressure will revert to canuckles b/c I predict you’ll be a bubble team (not enough goals in that lineup combined with porous d) and Miller is going to walk. What will you gm do 🧐?

No I did not forget he is a rental. Rentals get overplayed all the time though. Just ask Kyle Dubas.

Maybe one day your gm will have to make the tough call on what assets to trade add at deadline (rather than selling) for the playoffs… but looking at your lineup and prospect pool, it could be a while.