Edited Jun. 5, 2023 at 7:51 p.m.
Quoting: Billy739
Straight up capdumps with no cap coming back ?
-Bickell CHI gave up Panarin on a ELC
-Clarkson TML gave up a 1st and a 2nd round pick
-Datsyuk DET gave up a top 20 pick dump his cap
-Grabovski NYI gave up a 1st and 2nd round pick with Bischoff on ELC
-Ladd WPG paid a 1st and 2nd round pick with Dano on ELC
-Marleau TML gave up a 1st round pick to dump his cap
-Monahan CGY gave up a 1st round pick to dump his cap
The alternative is giving away players like VGK did with Reigning Vezina winner at the time MAF or with Pacioretty to CAR.
TBL downgraded from Mcdonugh to Myers to as they had not picks to pay to move him out at the time but needed cap cleared.
I can sight more Examples of this happening then Cal Peterson 2 year 5m contracts being taken on for a 1st round pick alone .
Those are just the one's i remembered and looked up the details on here to prove a point.
Given time i can find more im sure
But there's a reason why teams eat Shi* on bad contracts rather then move them out 9/10
MTL did it with Alzner cause the cost to dump him was too much
There's so much factually wrong with this, it's insane. I can't tell if you're being purposefully disingenuous or not. There are zero examples here of a team giving up a 1st round pick for a sub $4M cap hit.
1. Chicago gave up Teuvo Teräväinen, not Panarin. They also got back a 2nd and a 3rd round pick in the trade.
2. Clarkson was given up by Columbus along with a 1st + 2nd as part of the expansion draft so that Vegas would pick William Karlsson instead of one of their other quality young players. It's disingenuous to suggest that the picks were solely for the dump.
3. Detroit gave up the 20th overall pick (along with a 2nd and Joe Vitale), but they got the 16th overall pick back in the same draft. Again, you're either ignorant of the details or being disingenuous.
4. Grabovski - Like Columbus, this was part of the expansion draft and not just a cap dump.
5. Ladd - Winnipeg got a 1st round pick BACK for Ladd when they traded him to Chicago. They didn't pay a 1st. The Islanders later signed him as a UFA and traded his contract as a cap dump for a 2nd and a 3rd.
6. Marleau - Had a $6.25M cap hit on a 35+ contract with a NMC. There was no AHL cap relief waiting for him. Significantly more than Petersen's.
7. Monahan - Had a $6.375M cap hit. They could have buried him, but still his cap hit would have been in excess of $5M.
Funny you bring up Andrew Ladd, because his dump from the Islanders to Arizona is probably the most relevant here, and it only cost them a 2nd and a 3rd round pick. That's a reasonable comparable to dump Petersen's contract.