Hmmmm that would be interesting.

Brady is great , but he’s nowhere near his brothers level. Easy decline from Florida

I don't think either team does this. Dance with the Tkachuk you brought to the party!!!

Keep in mind Brady is two years younger and signed for 1.3m less per year.

Matthew's D+5 season: 56 GP 16 G 27 A 43 P 0.76ppg
Brady's D+5 season: 82 GP 35 G 48 A 83 P 1.01ppg

Matthew may very well turn out to be the better but the total numbers 5 seasons in are actually very similar if you crunch them.

It’s not just the production. Matthew is by far the best offense driving winger in the NHL. He’s also elite defensively. He does it all. It’s not a knock on Brady it’s more so Matthew being a borderline generational talent. He’s that good

Again I hear you but you could take those words and insert Brady for Matthew without many pundits batting an eye. On top of that I dont think anyone was talking about Matthew that way coming off that D+5 season. He really only made the strides to achieve that level of status the last two years. This year will be telling as to the comparison between the two but there's nothing within either of their first 5 years in the league to definitively give the nod one way or the other.

Brady’s biggest weakness is his defense

Both teams don’t do that for many reasons but if given the chance I’d rather have MT