SalarySwishSalarySwish
Forums/NHL

My Custom NHL 24 Player Ratings

Oct. 1, 2023 at 10:17 p.m.
#1
Avatar of the user
Joined: Jun. 2016
Posts: 3,151
Likes: 730
FORWARDS
Superstar: 92-99
Star: 89-92
1st Liner: 85-89
2nd Liner: 83-85
3rd Liner: 81-83
4th Liner: 78-81


DEFENSEMAN
Superstar: 92-99
Star: 89-92
#1 D-Man: 86-89
Top 4 D-Man: 82-86
3rd Pair D-Man: 78-82


GOALIES
Superstar: 92-99
Star: 89-92
Starter: 83-89
Backup: 78-83




FORWARDS

Connor McDavid 97
Nathan MacKinnon 95
Leon Draisaitl 94
Auston Matthews
Matthew Tkachuk 93
David Pastrnak
Jack Hughes 92
Mikko Rantanen
Kirill Kaprizov
Nikita Kucherov
Sidney Crosby
Jack Eichel
Mitchell Marner
Elias Pettersson
Brayden Point
Jason Robertson
Aleksander Barkov
Tage Thompson 91
Sebastian Aho
Roope Hintz 90
Nico Hischier
Tim Stutzle
Mark Stone
Brad Marchand
Artemi Panarin
Johnny Gaudreau 89
William Nylander
Jake Guentzel
Timo Meier
Andrei Svechnikov
Brady Tkachuk
Mika Zibanejad
Pavel Buchnevich
Sam Reinhart 88
Kevin Fiala
Clayton Keller
Alex Tuch
Kyle Connor
Mathew Barzal
Dylan Larkin
Nikolaj Ehlers
Pierre-Luc Dubois
Connor Bedard
Joe Pavelski
Steven Stamkos
Anze Kopitar
Alexander Ovechkin
Evgeni Malkin
Valeri Nichushkin
John Tavares
Ryan Nugent-Hopkins
Jonathan Marchessault
Matthew Boldy 87
Carter Verhaeghe
Robert Thomas
Matty Beniers
Joel Eriksson Ek
Jesper Bratt
Gabriel Landeskog
Elias Lindholm
Jonathan Huberdeau
Filip Forsberg
Jeff Skinner
Tomas Hertl
Bo Horvat
Mark Scheifele
Patrik Laine
Alex DeBrincat
Brock Nelson
Troy Terry
J.T. Miller
Logan Couture
Jared McCann 86
Claude Giroux
Jordan Kyrou
Travis Konecny
Jamie Benn
Nick Schmaltz
Adrian Kempe
Dylan Cozens
Cole Caufield
Nick Suzuki
Martin Necas
Zach Hyman
Jake DeBrusk
Brandon Hagel
Andrei Kuzmenko
Vincent Trocheck 85
Artturi Lehkonen
Dylan Strome
Chris Kreider
Josh Norris
Drake Batherson
Rickard Rakell
Chandler Stephenson
Trevor Zegras
Phillip Danault
Sean Couturier
Tyler Toffoli
Taylor Hall
Tyler Seguin
Patrick Kane
Ryan O'Reilly
Mats Zuccarello
Matt Duchene
Evander Kane
William Karlsson
Nazem Kadri
Alex Killorn
Logan Cooley 84
Andre Burakovsky
Jordan Eberle
Anthony Cirelli
Yanni Gourde
Viktor Arvidsson
Vladimir Tarasenko
Teuvo Teravainen
Lucas Raymond
Dawson Mercer
Tyler Bertuzzi
Mikael Backlund
Boone Jenner
Oliver Bjorkstrand
Max Pacioretty
Bryan Rust
Reilly Smith
Gabriel Vilardi
Brock Boeser
Tom Wilson
Ivan Barbashev
Sam Bennett
Jakub Vrana
Anders Lee
Nino Niederreiter
Pavel Zacha
Conor Garland
Andrew Mangiapane
Kirby Dach
Nicklas Backstrom
Brayden Schenn
David Perron
Ondrej Palat
J.T. Compher
Blake Wheeler
Adam Fantilli 83
Jesperi Kotkaniemi
Ryan Hartman
Ilya Mikheyev
Tomas Tatar
T.J. Oshie
Jordan Staal
Ryan Johansen
Ross Colton
Casey Mittelstadt
Filip Chytil
Alexis Lafreniere
Kaapo Kakko
Adam Henrique
Mason McTavish
Kent Johnson
Evgeny Kuznetsov
Owen Tippett
Max Domi
Michael Bunting
Alex Barabanov
Anthony Duclair
Brandon Saad
Quinton Byfield 82
Shane Wright
Jack Quinn
Cole Perfetti
Wyatt Johnston
Anton Lundell
Seth Jarvis
Anthony Beauvillier
Jonathan Toews
Joel Farabee
Cam Atkinson
Scott Laughton
Jean-Gabriel Pageau
Anthony Mantha
Barrett Hayton
Marcus Foligno
Charlie Coyle
Trevor Moore
Jason Zucker
Kyle Palmieri
Mason Marchment
Morgan Frost
Gustav Nyquist
Jaden Schwartz
Blake Coleman
Erik Haula
Will Carrier
Kevin Hayes
Evan Rodrigues
Alex Iafallo
Matias Maccelli
Lawson Crouse
Andrew Copp




DEFENSEMAN

Makar 94
Fox 92
Josi 91
McAvoy
Dahlin
Heiskanen
E Karlsson 90
Hamilton 89
Q Hughes
Slavin
D Toews
H Lindholm 88
Spurgeon
Sergachev
Hedman
Doughty
Burns
Pietrangelo
Theodore
Morrissey
Seider 87
Letang
Rielly
Ekholm
Andersson
Weegar
Werenski
S Jones
Chabot
Carlson
Bouchard 86
Dunn
Montour
Orlov
Chychrun
Dobson
Pelech
Brodin
Nurse
Pesce
Power
Hanifin 85
Ekblad
Marino
Severson
Byram
Girard
Brodie
Matheson
Hronek
Sandin
Sanderson 84
Skjei
Forsling
K Miller
Larsson
Lindgren
C Tanev
Walman
Jensen
Fowler
Martinez
Pulock
M Pettersson
Graves
Petry
Faulk
Trouba
McDonagh
Grzelcyk
Muzzin
Hague
Whitecloud
L Hughes 83
Clarke
York
Gavrikov
Parayko
Sanheim
Cernak
Gudas
Lindell
Siegenthaler
Krug
Carlo
M Anderson
Durzi
Roy
Zub
Jiricek 82
Nemec
Drysdale
Faber
Guhle
Samuelsson
Manson
Pionk
Demelo
Middleton
Dumba




GOALIES

Vasilevskiy 92
Hellebuyck
Sorokin
Shesterkin
Saros 91
Ullmark 88
Oettinger 88
Demko 87
Bobrovsky 86
Samsonov
Georgiev
Kuemper
Andersen
Hart
Gustavsson
Swayman 85
Gibson
Jarry
Fleury
Markstrom 84
Skinner
Vanacek
Raanta
Husso
Thompson
Hill
Binnington 83
Kochetkov
Varlamov
Lehner
Grubauer
Francouz
Merzlikins
Korpisalo
Forsberg
Wallstedt 82
Askarov
Knight
Levi
Wolf
Schmid
Campbell
Vejmelka
Copley
Quick 81
Montembault
Allen
Comrie
Brossoit
DeSmith



SABRES

F
Thompson 91
Tuch 88
Skinner 87
Cozens 86
Mittelstadt 83
Quinn 82
Benson 79
Greenway 79
Peterka 79
Krebs 79
Girgensons 79
Okposo 79
Olofsson 79
Kulich 78
Savoie 78
Jost 77
Biro 77
Rosen 77
Rousek 76
Ostlund 75


D
Dahlin 91
Power 86
Samuelsson 82
Clifton 81
Johnson 80
Jokiharju 79
Stillman 78
Bryson 76
Clague 76
Johnson 76


G
Levi 82
Comrie 81
Luukkonen 80
Tokarski 76
Oct. 1, 2023 at 10:37 p.m.
#2
Avatar of the user
Joined: May 2019
Posts: 40,178
Likes: 18,355
I know these are for the video game, but are they meant to be for trade values? ie,

Player A (88) + Player B (82) = 170
Player X (94) + Player Z (76) = 170

Shouldn’t they be on more of logarithmic scale?
Oct. 2, 2023 at 12:22 a.m.
#3
Banned
Avatar of the user
Joined: Sep. 2023
Posts: 33
Likes: 7
WHERE IS TYLER PITLICK?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?Very Angry
Oct. 2, 2023 at 1:01 a.m.
#4
Avatar of the user
Joined: May 2022
Posts: 8,566
Likes: 3,319
Quoting: NHLfan10506
I know these are for the video game, but are they meant to be for trade values? ie,

Player A (88) + Player B (82) = 170
Player X (94) + Player Z (76) = 170

Shouldn’t they be on more of logarithmic scale?


Nah, in the new games potential, age, morale, and contract situation along with overall affect the trade value. More recently, they even made it so that the time of the year for rentals like the trade deadline or prior to free agency affects the player values as well.
Oct. 2, 2023 at 8:59 a.m.
#5
Bedard23
Avatar of the user
Joined: May 2021
Posts: 9,297
Likes: 4,476
Buchnevich over Connor is a war crime

Also don’t get me wrong, Hintz is amazing, but he’s not a 90, same with Hischer, he’s definitely not a 90
 
Reply
To create a post please Login or Register
Question:
Options:
Add Option
Submit Poll