If Duclair is on a 30+ goal pace I could see that return, if it’s 20-30 we may have to add a 4th going back.
Less than 20 goal pace and that 1st is a pipe dream.

But I do appreciate fair returns so thanks for not trolling people.

This is fair for a bounceback Duclair.

Foegele's better than McBain or Duclair

Yeah def McBain, but Foegs had a career last year while Duclair had the opposite. At their normal rate Duclair is better as much as I love Foegs

Sharks only have a single spot for retention left, but Duclair's out of contract at the end of this season anyway. And a 1st plus a 5th isn't a bad return at all. Jury's out for me, but this is a trade I could see the Sharks accepting.

How are the oilers paying to downgrade doesn’t make any sense

I’m sorry but duclair is not worth a first at best he’s worth a 2nd San Jose would make that trade as fast as possible but the oilers would never

30 goal guy for 1.5 mil for a cup run isn’t crazy. This years TDL will be about bargains more than impact. And impact players at a bargain will be highly sought after! So while I'm not disagreeing with you I am saying this isn’t out of the realm of possibility, though more offense isn’t what the oilers need.

AZ is not trading a 23 yo C who led F in hits as a rookie for a W and picks ( when they have a million already)

Oilers aren't using their 2024 first on a forward....