In my somewhat biased opinion

1.Forrester
2A.York
2B.Holloway



3.Broberg

Foerster
York
Holloway
Broberg

I think both Philly players are better than the two Oilers players. York>Broberg. TF > Holloway. The only caveat is that I think Holloway might have a bigger upside than TF.

Foerster
York
Holloway










Broberg

I would go:

York
Forester
Broberg (his unhappiness with his situation may make him #4 though. But if that were not there he would be #3... maybe #2)
Holloway

I'm not unbiased, but the Flyers players are much better than the Oilers players. In addition both Flyers are more proven at the NHL level.

I’m a NYR fan and Foerster and York definitely above Holloway and Broberg at this point. I’m a big Foerster fan. Love the way he plays. Plays a very good defensive game for such a young player. Torts even giving him compliments on the defensive side, so that says something. He also has a great shot, quick release, can play C or wing. Don’t thing top line but def solid 2nd/3rd for a long time.

As an oilers fan I feel like you're far too high on Broberg and far too low on Holloway. Holloway has been fairly dominant on the ice as of recently but pucks just haven't bounced his way, he looks much fresher back from injury and has found himself in Edmontons middle 6 finally. Now he hasn't proven anything yet but I wouldn't be shocked if he scores 20 next year or has a 20 goal pace after the all star break.

I'd be shocked if Broberg even plays in the NHL full time.