Joined: Jan. 2018
Posts: 17,230
Likes: 12,268
I love Karl SO MUCH, but for a deal to make sense in my head for Ottawa, there's too many moving pieces to ever actually make sense. You'd borderline need to completely rebuild the entire blueline to support him, like full EA NHL style.
-Chabot has to be going the other way or be dealt separately. Both are great players, but if you're bringing in EK65, you're building the top powerplay around him, and you still want Sanderson developing with those PP2 reps.
-You're getting Karlsson at 8mil or lower. Any higher than that and it's just too big a gamble imo.
-You're maybe also considering trying to swap Chychrun out for a big minute defensive LD instead. Maybe Chychrun and Karlsson could work together idk, but Karlsson does his best with a steady hand behind him, and I don't think Chychrun is built for cleanup duty. Maybe there's a world where you convince the Rangers to make a Miller/Chychrun swap or something?
-If you're making a play for Karlsson, you're pushing your chips in to try and win with Karlsson while he's still Karlsson. That means you're going out and making a big move to get a great goalie too. Which means like, Markstrom, Saros or maybe Ullmark in the summer. That's after you deal with Korpisalo (definitely not in the Karlsson trade), probably via a buyout.
Ultimately I think that unless you're gonna fully commit to changing around Karlsson, adding Karl just doesn't make sense. Merely adding EK To this team doesn't really address any of the actual issues with the blueline.