Shatty has repeatedly said he'll never sign with a Canadian team.

Wanna know a funny thing? It was reported by Seravalli when he spoke to his agent at least year's trade deadline that Toronto would be the only Canadian team he would be willing to be traded to

Source?

Seravalli isn't one.

Sorry updated my comment. It was from Seravalli, if I remember correctly, he said he spoke with his agent

Do we believe that Benoit is legit a top 4 guy???

Ohh hell yeah. He isn't a fancy name but he gets the job done. I would honestly save he's been our second best defensemen, first being McCabe

Rielly is the only actual top 4D Leafs have but they somehow make it work in the regular season.

Playoffs? 😬

Where's TimmyL?

I’m not here to dispute that. But then you’ll need to pay him like a top 4/top 2 guy. 1.3M is laughable. 2.5+ easy

No but he could be a top 4, some day, he isn’t now and he needs to put a lot of work to become one, but he could, same with xhekaj

Absolutely not. Real solid bottom pair guy though who is physical and limits dangerous chances.



He just signed for 3 x 1.35

McCabe's a top 4, easily. Lily *when he's playing at his best* is as well. Can be inconsistent though.

No on Liljegren.

Did he even play in the playoffs last year?

McCabe is probably a #4.

Yeah, 5 games. And that's part of the inconsistency I mentioned. He was probably our 2nd best Dman last year right up until the deadline. And then he started struggling. I don't know if it's a mental thing, like he was worried he was gonna lose his spot or what, but like I said - when he's at his best.

Not gonna bother pushing back against McCabe. If you wanna say #4, fine. He's a legit 2nd pair guy in this league.

Bahah, Liljegren is a 7th defensemen on a contender

Cool man