Quoting: Matt1567
so why give up a 3rd for him when you can get an equally good or even better player through free agency, he's just an example but Teddy Blueger is a free agent this summer who's 52.8% on faaceoffs this season, they can pay more than he is worth since they have so much cap space and he'll do the same job as Eller but without costing the team a 3rd
Quoting: SociallyHawkward
Again if the hawks feel the need to bring in a faceoff specialist, that can be done in free agency without giving up assets.
I think you are making pretty big assumption that those players don't have other options. C is a need position and those guys can end up going to teams in the hunt.
Since you mentioned Blueger, what reason does Blueger have to sign in CHI where he can continue playing for JR in Van who he has a relationship with and has always been fair to him. Does it surprise you he ended up there to begin with?
There are multiple teams looking for center help. Either to replace what they have, or to fill a whole.
They aren't just growing on trees.
Blueger, which has no reason to leave VAN, Monahan will cost an arm and a leg given how he plays in WPG and doesn't really make sense for CHI. Wennberg isn't a great faceoff guy or defensive center, Carrick maybe but he's probably picked up on a winning team after getting out of ANA. Not sure he wants back on another rebuilding team.
So finding a Vet who is a solid face off guy to help teach isn't as easy to find in FA as you might think. C market is pretty empty at begin with and there are other teams that have needs.
Eller is a really good fit for that on a 1 year deal with a reasonable cap hit. You over here acting like giving up a 3rd round pick is something. Those players have a 16% chance turning into an NHL player that plays 200 games. Let alone an actual good one. It's not like they are giving up their 1st round pick. It's a small price to pay man. Hell it's so little it's an after thought on a Post about NCAA free agents. Get over it.