Monahan realistic value

Easy no to both. Raty still has the potential to be a cirelli esce player. Wahlstrom had a chance to be great but I think NYI ruined his potential and confidence

Value is probably fair for Monahan but i expect someone to beat that offer closer to deadline IMHO
Raty’s issue is speed, right? Talented but slow?

If you don't like the asking price for Monahan then why don't you just find another player to acquire instead of debating what you believe he's actually worth ?

MTL will have a high asking price for this player because he will be in high demand. It's fine if you don't want to pay that price, just move on to another option.

This. Context is lost on the loudest here.

Trying to explain to doubters that Monahan is worth a 1st is the same mundane task as explaining the merits of Ben Chiarot and the marketplace opportunity. It's an open market with 31 other teams bidding.

You think he aint worth it, fine, but deal with it because other teams want a low cost AAV, w/o trade protection center that wins draws and can cary a line to the tune of a 50 point pace.

He's been carrying Gallagher and Evans, two 4th liners yet produces. Teams see that and want that kind of depth not to mention that same depth carried Vegas to a Stanley Cup.

I'm sure if another UFA in William Carrier form Vegas was available he'd go for a 1st yet he has less than half of Monahan's point totals.

If someone is willing to pay a 1st for him, that is on them. He is by no means worth a 1st. Not with his 4 goals and 7 assists 5v5.

He's on pace for Brandon Tanev numbers (in terms of goals and points, Tanev is much better physically and defensively). That is to say, he is a pretty good 3rd liner. If someone pays a 1st for a good 3rd liner (not great, good), they are at risk of being fired, very soon.