Who adds what?
Joined: Jul. 2017
Posts: 13,677
Likes: 2,703
You're offering Carlson 8.5M, and the Caps have publicly said they're not sure another team will offer him 8M, so you think that gets him? If he wants to be a Maple Leaf, he's certainly free to go there, but 6x8.5=51M. The Caps counter with an eight year deal at a cap hit of 7M. 7x8=56. They front load it a bit, and he gets to keep playing with his friends and make more money, short and long term.
You've got more cap space, but it's pretend cap space, because none of your "trades" appeal remotely to any other team's needs or goals. So as a Caps fan who hopes Carlson sticks around, I'm not worried by your amateur low-balling, short-term offer.
You signed Tavares for 8 years, but you didn't trade for his rights, so you can only offer him 7. Again, if you offer him 7x12.5, NYI counter with 8x11.5, and they've won by a mile. Trading away all of your bad contracts and signing all of the best UFAs for cheap only happens when your playstation is set on the easy level. In the NHL, the other teams want to win, too.