Edited Oct. 28, 2018 at 6:51 p.m.
Quoting: Ciccarelli22andOvi8
Also, if you take it at a PPG average than Bura is 12th and Simmonds is tied for six in their respective draft classes. AND, Simmonds has guys inhis draft class like P.Kane, JVR, Pacoretty(sp), Benn and Couture in front of him, Buras class ain't so good
Monahan, MacKinnon, Barkov, Horvat, Lindholm, Burakovsky, Domi, Guentzel, Jones, Mantha, Har[t]man, Drouin, Duclair, Wennberg...Wood...Ristolainen...Nicushkin... yeah. It's a pretty good group. They're just not old yet. Look back at the immediate coverage of Simmonds (plus picks and prospects) for Mike Richards. Then look at the more recent coverage after Richards came out of retirement to play 4C for the Caps while Simmonds played on the Flyers' top line. Hockey players peak, on average, around age 27. Kane's early years were buoyed by playing with Toews and Hossa. The rest of Simmonds' draft class didn't look like anything at the time.
edit: JVR, through his age 22 season, had 47 goals, with 39 at evens (
https://www.hockey-reference.com/players/v/vanrija01.html). Bura had 50, 44.
Pacioretty through age 22, had 20 NHL goals, including 12 at even strength. Burakovsky had 50, 44.
Kane and Benn are pretty good.
2nd edit: If you look at Kane and Benn's draft class, five years after they were picked, Burakovsky ties for 7th in even strength goals with Couture, at 44. Time-traveling Burakovsky lands 8th in points, behind Couture, but ahead of Pacioretty and James Van Riemsdyk, whom Flyers and Leafs fans seem to think is decent?
http://www.nhl.com/stats/player?aggregate=1&report=skatergoals&reportType=season&seasonFrom=20062007&seasonTo=20112012&gameType=2&draftYear=2007&filter=gamesPlayed,gte,1&sort=evGoals
In that last link, Burakovsky's 120 points in the first five years from his draft day are 34 better than Kevin Shattenkirk, 44 better than PK Subban, 77 better than Lars Eller, whom the Caps just extended for five years, 82 better than Carl Hagelin, who turned out okay, and 100 better than Nick Bonino. He's definitely slumping right now, but something tells me he's going to pull through. If you don't believe in counting, then let's just call it a hunch.
I will say there's one cautionary tale on that list: Sam Gagner had a lot of points, from playing consistent first line minutes and top power play time with Edmonton. He still holds Edmonton's record for points in a single game, which is saying something, because some pretty good hockey players have played for Edmonton. The last time he got a shot on any team's second line, he still got fifty points, so I still think he's pretty good, but Vancouver fans turned on him as expensive, and he got waived this fall.