Joined: Aug. 2016
Posts: 32
Likes: 7
You're missing some other assets, too, and that isn't even counting the butterfly effect that the deals had.
Assets lost:
Zibanejad
2018 2nd (Jonatan Berggren)
2018 3rd (Justus Annunen)
Vincent Dunn (would have been unqualified anyways)
Assets gained:
Gustavsson
Nick Moutrey (not qualified)
2018 1st (Jacob Bernard-Docker)
2018 2nd (Jonathan Tychonick)
2018 7th (Luke Loheit)
2019 3rd (PIT)
2020 3rd (CBJ)
Dunn and Moutrey are a wash. Let's say that the cost of moving up from 33rd (the Berggren pick) to 26th (the Bernard-Docker pick) is the 64th pick (the Annunen pick), so those are balanced out, leaving us with:
Zibanejad being traded for Gustavsson, a mid-2nd round pick (48th, Tychoniak), a 7th round pick (Loheit), and 3rd round picks in both 2019 and 2020. All told, the trade is a middle of the road 2C (Zibanejad is 44th among centers in P/GP the past two seasons, min 45GP) for a top flight goalie prospect and four lottery tickets of varying value. It really doesn't look bad on the Sens, especially with the sheer number of prospects added in the net deal.