Dougie trade is missing Marner at 5M retained

That type of deal hasn’t been and never will be an acceptable one for Hamilton.

Rumor is that Boston is the front runner to sign Dadonov

Hahaha

Wings still pass

Dadonov is very unnecessary, Hamilton trade as much as everyone will scream not enough is ridiculous overpayment for a guy with no contract and loves playing in Carolina

hahaha...

I'm not kidding.

The problem is that it's just quantity and none of it makes the difference up.

AJ --> Pretty sure it's obvious that no one even wants him
Andersen --> Although a good goalie, they can be had for free with the surplus on the market
Liljegren --> Good prospect, doesn't move the needle
2nd --> useless

Wow. LOL

Everyone on here keeps proclaiming that loudly but...

That's more or less the precedent for acquiring a top end impending UFA for a season

Former MVP Hall required less (for 2/3 of a season)
Tyson "almost top end" Barrie required about that
Future HOFer Karlsson required a fair bit more

Can we all agree that Dougie's value is between Hall/Barrie? If so that package is pretty good.

At worst Leafs would need to ramp it up a bit

Could have fooled me, I assumed you were a stand up comedian.

Why would the Wings want Reimer? Yeah and that doesn't come nearly close to getting Dougie Hamilton.

Please don't let this particularly salty peanut gallery get to you, this is the one of the best TMLAGMs yet

Dado & Weegs are both super underrated
You made good use of the young talent
Dougie is a perfect fit and 100% worth it
Those goalies give lg avg sv% for 2.6M
Nic Hague is a sneaky good prospect

My issues are Janko instead of Koivu/Leivo and yeah a bit more is needed to many of the trades to make them work fully, otherwise super cool beans

Ok counter proposal then,

Matthews for Reimer, Bean, Necas, and a 2nd

You're right, Dougie is worth it. But this isn't really giving anything up.

He isn’t between hall and barrie.

A bottom half goalie from last year with one year left, a long term project defender, a shoulder injury LW, and a 2nd has little value.

Can we get Nylander for Reimer, Bean, McGinn and a 2nd? No? Why not?

How much term is left on Hamilton, isn't he coming off a knee injury as well

Leafs fans gotta Leafs fan.

Hamilton has returned and looked normal.

So did AJ

1 game for 12 minutes, sure

All the arguments your spitting work both ways, Freddie has also had numerous Vezina nominations over the last 4 seasons hasn't won it but has certainly been in the conversation, Hamilton has been in the conversation for a Norris twice but yet still hasn't won it

Cool. The package is bad. Hamilton is staying. Moving on.

One thing I'll say is Hamilton has ALREADY been traded TWICE and both times it was for was less then this. And he was way younger. He's a ufa next year. Good luck

I can’t help two tells sold him because of a made up, unsourced message that has followed him, and because Boston couldnt afford him.

We don’t want luck moving him. We’ll keep him.