Edited Feb. 28, 2021 at 6:47 p.m.
Quoting: TanSor
I agree with you, but if we could get him for Rossi, Dumba, and two firsts this year then I say pull the trigger. Unless we get a top 10 pick and get Beniers, Johnson, or Eklund in this year's draft, the pickings are very slim for center prospects (in my opinion, I don't really like Raty and L'Heureux, Lucius is probably an NHL wing) and we don't really have an immediate need for defenseman or winger prospects.
He's not McDavid, but there are only a handful of centers that can score 90+ points in a season and even fewer that are under 25 and signed long term.
Unless we have a legitimate shot at either Beniers or Johnson we shouldn't be concerned or consider centers in this draft anyway.
I disagree, I wouldn't say the need for a defenseman is immediate, but we absolutely should be looking to draft a top pairing potential LHD to replace Suter in this years draft, in the most defense heavy draft in the past decade and where all but two are LHD and all project to be a top 2 or top 4 defenseman.
Picking up both O'Rourke and Hunt during last years draft went a long way to shoring up the defensive prospect pool on the left but we still need a top pairing guy as we still have a need and hole for one there. O'Rourke is a great prospect but doesn't project to be anything better than a 2nd pairing defenseman, which is fine because he'll be the perfect partner for Addison. Hunt projects out to be a 3rd pairing player.
Suter is 35 and can't stay up there for too much longer, Eichel or no Eichel. Sure, Brodin could slide up there and take over for awhile but we still would need a prospect in the system within at least the next two drafts to cover for Suter's downturn. I'm just not sold he makes it until the end of his contract.
The 2022 draft is shaping up to be as good as or better than the 2015 draft. It's center deep, and also has some very good defensive prospects as well... all of whom who are righty's. There's also just about zero goalies that are worthwhile in it.
In my opinion we'd be blowing our God's gift to drafting a Suter replacement for the here and now. That isn't to say Eichel isn't a worthwhile trade-off, but it's not just about contending for a 2-3 year window in my eyes, but making sure we have a team that can contend for a decade plus. It would be smarter to make a play for one of the three franchise centers that will come out of the 2022 draft instead, all of which have a floor of say a Barkov. That would give us much better depth down the middle and make for a stronger contender in two to three years time than going after Eichel. One of Wright/Lambert/Savoie, Rossi, Eriksson-Ek, Sturm is a much better team and would allow us to maximize our current prospect pool.
To that end, I would also think we should seriously consider drafting Wallstedt as well. I recognize fully that we have Kahkonen, as well as Jones and Lindberg in the system as well. But none of them project to be a franchise goalie. Besides, by the time Wallstedt would be ready to come into the NHL, Talbot's contract will be done and Kahkonen will likely be just hitting his 30's. This would give us a solid goaltending tandem for a decade plus as well. All the more crucial for a cup contending team.
Just my two cents.