No

Who's the current All-Star Arizona is getting in return for All-Star Jakob Chychrun?

For that matter, who's the All-Star POSSIBILITY Arizona is getting in return for All-Star Jakob Chychrun?

That's perhaps the worst trade offer for a player the quality of Chychrun/Fox/Makar/Sergachev I've ever seen on CapFriendly.

you dont know your prospects well then.

also many all stars get traded for player who are not or just for picks and prospects.
example. Fluery traded for nothing S jones for boquist. hall for larsson, palmari late 1st

Sharks aren’t retaining $19 million and giving you their two best players for that.

Firstly, you need to give up 2 first round equivalents for Hertl, secondly Hill is worth a second and some, and you'd have to give up a few more high picks for taking on all that money.

I agree they wouldnt.

however statistically yes top players. Kane however probably has the worst trade value in the league right now. I dont think they can even give him away.

Another example of someone wildly overvaluing players on his favorite team.

I know that Turris is a pure cap dump.

I know that Lagesson is unlikely to ever be more than a third-pairing defenseman.

I know that Broberg is an A prospect, but HIGHLY unlikely to ever be as good as Chychrun.

I know that Ralph "The Sled" Lavoie is a B prospect whose skating may keep him from ever being a top-6 forward.

I know that right now, Tyler Tullio is not regarded as more than a B prospect.

I know that a 2023 first won't hit the NHL until 2025-2026, if then, if ever.

Jakob Chychrun would be the third most-valuable player on your team, well above Ryan Nugent-Hopkins or Darnell Nurse and head and shoulders above anyone else including prospects in your system (even Evan Bouchard).

And if you think that Seth Jones got traded for Adam Boqvist, or that a declining Kyle Palmieri is anywhere close to the value of Chychrun, God help you.

point is all start players get traded for picks and prospects all the time... pretty much every trade very rarely is it allstar for allstar.

In your case ARZ is clearly not in the win now mode or will be any time soon. so getting another alstar player back will mean that player asking for a trade anyways.
more time than not for an all star player its a 1st rounder an A prospect a B prospect and then some other later pick with a condition so pretty much met here if not more.

regardless i would not do this trade from edmonton stand point i would rather keep broberg lavoie and the 1st it will more holes that the oilers have need in than chychrun does. Oiler core is set they just need depth

also not sure you can call palmieri declining he had one off year last year. other than that 5 straight years of 45-50 points and 24 + goals each season so good help you if you think he does still have value.

as for LAvoie I haven't heard anywhere about foot speed holding him back. yes not his strongest attribute most scouts still project him as a top 6 RW

lets look at this

Koskinen and a 3rd to dump his contract
Kassian and a 2nd to dump his contract
Hertl for yamamoto, petrov and a 1st
Hill for Benson

What are you paying for the retention?