I can't decide if this trade would be more detrimental to the Leafs or Nylander for Parayko next off-season as suggested by some "rumor" site (not sure if they wanted Nylander+future for Parayko or a 1 for 1).

LOL i love Reilly and Willy, dont want them to trade either player. looking at the leafs strengths at LD i think they could realistically move Reilly for a strong RHD and not miss a step.

In general since Rielly has been out Leafs PP has been 2/23 would rather just keep him

Moving Nylander or Rielly would be a mistake imo. If Rielly were to be moved it would need to be a RD who is equivalent but no team is taking that trade if that's the case.

The Leafs just need to lock their guys and continue practicing patience.

Faulk is 2 years older than Rielly and signed for 4 more years.
Parayko is a year older than Rielly, same term and 1m cheaper, I don't think they are going to get an impact player with that 1m, So, it comes down to Rielly vs Parayko.

I would take Rielly over either guy because Faulk probably only has 4 more good years in him and it's much easier to just get a defensively sound guy to pair with Rielly, or go with Brodie and just wait for Liljegren to continue developing and perhaps Niemela in the future. There is definitely going to be a trade-off if you trade Rielly for either guy, and I don't think the improvement overall to the team after that move would be significant and it might have a negative impact too.

This would probly get you guys a cup to be honest, I think STL would want more though.

I honestly couldn’t see Stl doing this
I mean for arguments sake faulk and Reilly have to be pretty close in value to each other. Meaning this is almost ROR for Kerfoot and a 2nd which isn’t close to his asking price

This is not terribly close in value, AND doesn;t suit the Blues' needs at all.

This doesn't do anything for the blues. It makes us worse currently and does nothing to help us rebuild/retool