That CHI offer probably gets one player or the other but not both.

McCabe, alone, is an over payment, but the 3 yrs of retention is worth more than the 1st rounder

We shouldn't trade Sandin. Only way I think we move him, is if Chychrun is coming back. But even in that case, I would prefer to keep him.

Also, in this circumstance, just keep Holl. I don't get trading him for nothing. He has averaged over 21mins a game and has been quite solid this year. He would fit under the cap and give us a lot more defensive depth.

If we consider Sandin equal to a 1st round pick, this is probably close value-wise. But I'm not sure how much interest CHI will have in adding another LHD or if they would even value Sandin that highly. They'd probably rather have picks or prospects.

Based on the Rumor Patrick Kane will only accept Trade to either NYR or Leafs then trade is fair.
We can argue Holl's value (pure dump). This may be enough but, I think not impact enough to get us into the second round of the playoffs.
My take MEH

I wouldn't pay for either