I may be wrong but I think you’re way too optimistic across the board on the returns these players would get.

I think I was too optimistic on the gustafsson one but I feel the others are fair

Gustafsson probably gets a second round pick for the role he plays and his cap hit. Gotta sell high on him. Orlov getting a first with retention is very possible depending on where he goes. Eller probably gets a fourth. I'd want a second and a third for Sheary. Johansson return makes sense, as does NAK.

high on gustafsson but that's it

We have zero need for a defensemen. Who’s he starting over? Is that really the best use of assets when we have a glaring need at a top 6 winger with Stone out?