Quoting: dopplsan
- Never said Severson was the problem? But also if you think he’s the only thing propping it up, you aren’t paying attention.
Not open to trading because he’s bad, but because his contract is not likely to age well and was signed under different circumstances - Jarmo making the poor decision to trade and sign for a guy as if their window of contention is right now. CBJ have a number of good prospects coming up the chain who can fill his role as a middle-pairing D.
- “The defense market sucks” actually inclines me to trade him even more. If you’re telling me I could put Severson on the market and he’d represent the top-end of it, I’m putting myself in a position to get a prime asset.
You’re basically making the point to me that CBJ shouldn’t settle on a trade like this for Severson, and they can/should get more in a seller’s market. Problem is, moving that kind of cap in a league that is still flat-capped is very difficult; there needs to be money-in-money-out.
you think he's a bad contract on the team. I don't think he is.
Those young players need stability around them and on the back end.
He brings that. It's not like defensemen are just going to "go bad" past 30. The vast majority of them play fairly well into their mid 30s. It's not a horrible contract.
So the whole isn't going to age well argument doesn't mean much. You need defensemen who can help a young forward group in CBJ. 6 of their top 9 are 23 or younger.
Next year with them drafting top 5 it will probably be 7.
You need those vets to provide not only leadership but also stability in the play. If the game is shaky behind them things fall apart.
Which is why I say if you want Guddy I'm sure they could make a deal. But I don't see them moving out a stable guy for a young developing core as it's hard for them to replace that.
If they did move him out, you are looking at it having to be a really good deal. Not one they are taking back a cap dump, etc...
You have to realize CBJ isn't the most attractive place to land free agents. So it's not like they can easily replace guys on the market.
It's why they tend to develop their own players. Between not being a draw and not being deep pockets that's how it is.
But they need to have that stability to help all those young players grow. It's one of the arguments as to why Boon Jenner is more valuable to CBJ than anywhere else.
On the backend for CBJ Severson, Provorov and Werenski are the guys who can provide that stability. Everyone else is sketchy at best. You'd leave them with 2 defensemen.