Avatar

chuck28

Member Since
Jul. 18, 2016
Forum Posts
341
Posts per Day
0.1
Forum: Armchair-GMJan. 5 at 3:32 p.m.
Thread: To montreal fans
i don't think he will be traded to MTL for multiple reason
1- MTL is in rebuild now
2- MTL will restart to compete (at least we hope) when he will be UFA around 24-25
3- He would hurt our rebuild if he come now
4- The price would be to high
5- If he sign somewhere else , he sign somewhere else and that's it, he is not available anymore, case close.

So basicaly in my opinion the timing is simply not now. We don't even know where we will draft yet , we will have good lottery chance maybe Bedard (if we are lucky enough) or top 5 could give us Fantili or Carlson and we can have our second centre in a couple of years(around 24-25 , 25-26). Probably one or two year later then if we sign PLD as UFA.

the point is IF he come to MTL it will be as UFA in 2024 summer not before . It will hurt the team's future to much if he come before that . (as the price to aquire him in the first place but we have to add the ranking of our draft pick during our rebuildt hat would be lower quality)
Forum: Armchair-GMDec. 25, 2022 at 9:40 a.m.
Thread: habs 22-23 TDL hope
<div class="quote"><div class="quote_t">Quoting: <b>TheeDjeeEem</b></div><div>with 50% retention on

Hoffman, Mike
Drouin, Jonathan
Dadonov, Evgeni

You'd be <strong>lucky</strong> to receive a 4/5th

Edmundson at 50% is worth a 2nd... if you're lucky because he's just not very talented anymore

Monahan at 50% is worth a 1st OR a top prospect if youre lucky because he's always injured and a rental

So that's 5 retentions to receive 3 5th's, or a 2nd, or a 1st... seems like Drouin/Dad should just play out their bad deal.

Hoffman is a lockeroom/media cancer, even at 2x2.25.

Monahan to COL/BOS/TOR makes most sense.

Edmundson to EDM or FLA makes sense for THEM, do YOU want to help them at the cost of a '23 2nd?</div></div>

thanks for the feed back

so basicaly its just Edmunson that we don't get along for the value

Drouin,Dadonov, Hoffman for 4/5 round if retain is around mid to late (but we could only retain on one if we retain on Monahan and Edmunson)
so we can accept 6/7 round with no retention or
i agree with you and have no problem to just wait till the end for Drouin and Dadonov (this summer) that's why i said 3 on 5
and Monhan half retain for a 1st round that's what we want i add a grade B prospect in the trade but the possibility to add on MTL side too to compensate but Monahan for a 1st straigt up i am ok with it

but i think with 2 years of retain salary on Edmunson if we add a mid round (or value of) we can get a 1st OR a good prospect

so i am not too far off overall
Forum: Armchair-GMJul. 16, 2022 at 10:19 a.m.
Thread: Giving Bedard to clear cap
heh no!!
what about Byron on LTIR or trade with a 3th or 4th round for 7th or future considaration
i was about to continue but i just saw that i was about to repeat <a href="/users/jonh514" target="_blank" rel="noreferrer noopener">@jonh514</a> comment
so i will just put it in quote for you to see it again
<div class="quote"><div class="quote_t">Quoting: <b>jonh514</b></div><div>Why do you feel the Habs need to clear all that space? Byron is probably on LTIR for the last year of his deal, but can buried in the minors to save 1M if not.
Dadonov can be bought out for 667K this season and 2.1M next season.
What are you planning to do with the cap space?</div></div>

i will add there is no good point in paying to clear cap space if you don't used that cap space for something else.