For all the leafs fans

Trust me, I know leafs fans can be a little stupid.

But Mayfield is AT BEST, the 4th best D man on the Islanders. You're likely getting a 2nd and a very good prospect for him, there's no world where he returns a first. Chiarot is different because that's a pro-rated 1 year deal where it doesn't matter after July 1st (in a normal year, I know free agency doesn't start this year until like the 14th)

I think the Isle should keep their star defensive defenceman who allows more goals against than any other defenceman on their team. He may find some success sometimes on a defence only scheme like Trotz employs but he's not in the top 6 on any team that requires possession and movement. He's not worth a 1st. He may not even be worth a 4th. In Keefe's system, he wouldn't play.

He's the best isle defenceman.....at getting scored on this year. Literally has been on the ice for over a quarter of their goals against. People on here just don't bother looking into anything. They just read what fans say and accept it as long as it agrees with their opinion.

Which is why all non leaf fans know all leaf depth players suck. Despite being a top 5 team, no one outside of their core 4 would make any other team somehow. Which means somehow that the core 4 both are overrated and also carry the depth to top 5 in the NHL heights because none of them will ever make any other team.

If you can explain that logic then you can call Leaf fans stupid.

At 1.45 the 2nd year is quite an asset not a negative.

We've had many conversations on many threads on the mayfield subject but you still havent been able to give me 1 reason why if savard and chiarot get 1sts mayfield doesnt? You give me your own reasoning on why he isnt worth a 1st and keefes system and a system supposedly perfect for him but gms have clearly shown that they value those types of players, and are willing to pay a 1st for them. Actual nhl gms not pleasebanmeformyowngood on capfriendly. So as politely as possible i couldnt give 2 f*cks why you think mayfield shouldnt get a 1st. I want to know why you think he wont given the price gms will pay for his comparables.