Quoting: TheRiddler
For 28, it's not very interesting. We give two best strikers,except Jack, of course. Vladi, and a one-year lease Zuccarello and 28? No thanks. 9 peak is of great importance in such a deal, 1-10 a lot of cool players, then there are less interesting guys.
Since O'Reilly has requested a trade, his value, though high, can be matched by Zuccarello. Adding Smith on defense, gives your defense a player who can help your team compete over the next three seasons while your rebuild continues. If anything, Zuccarello is a chip for more prospects/picks in a future deal.
Namestnikov becomes a long-term piece to add to Eichel. There's enough great young players in the first 60-90 picks to prepare to have an impactful draft after Dahlin.
Another thing is, if Botteril wants a team to take the whole contract (5 @ $7.5m), and uphold a trade request, Zuccarello and Namestnikov is actually an overpayment; I already dropped Beleskey from this deal: I added two defensemen in Smith and Gilmour because of Buffalo's need.
Lastly, taking #9 from us hurts the Rangers' own rebuild. Do they forfeit the future while taking away the malcontents from Buffalo's locker room?