Quoting: Username_Bot
meh... I honestly don't really think Backes is that bad. A change of scenario can definitely change him, except no one wants him. Last year he had a 0.64 point/game ratio, and honestly that is very good for a 3rd/4th liner. He just has an insane cap and NMC. You are overwaying value of Panarin, who isn't going to sign in, we all know that. You are asking for 2 top 6 F, a top 4 D, a first, and a 3/4 rounder to get rid of Backes and Panarin. 1, Backes is easy to get rid of for a 2nd, senyshyn with 1M retained. We can't do that because Backes has NMC. Panarin is worth Heinen and a few below avg prospects and a first. Just saying, both Panarin and bob will probably not sign, so better get rid of them for even low value instead allowing them to walk.
First of all, no, it isnt smart to trade them especially when the return will be "heinen and a couple below average prospects and a first." We are the best metro team right now and have a bad reputation. We need to make a name for ourselves and push for the cup. Trading bread and Bob would get our front office under major scrutiny.
Also, dont act like Backes is that good. Hes a 34 year old with THREE years left who is playing like a 13F. Hes horrible. 4.5 million is over 3 million more than what hes worth. Nobody is taking that contract from you unless you retain more and throw in some very good picks and prospects. We are already having a few young guys that are gonna be getting paid in the next few years, taking in Backes contract would be the dumbest move possible.
If you're asking for an absolutely elite winger, and for us to take one of the worst contracts in the league (even at 4.5) you're gonna have to give up a ton more. Heinen, a first, third and Cehlarik might give you just panarin. To take backes contract, one of donato/bjork/vaakainen has to be coming back, plus another pick (probably 2019 second) and a high level prospect. You're WAY undervaluing bread, even as a rental, and way overvaluing backes.
I wouldnt actually be surprised if we ended up tanking, trading bread, and your gm overpays for him to try to win one last cup while Rask, Chara, Bergeron, and Krejci are still good