If we follow your description, Hayes should not be here because he didn’t show if the contract he sign worth, plus petty is worth his money, and Suter too, but suter wont worth in 3-4 years for sure

And if anders lee Ian there skinner should be there, because both scored 40 goals last year but skinner make 2M more

I'd put Skinner on before Lee, and Smith or Talbot (or Vasy) on before Bob and I'd put a ton of guys on before Petry (Weber and Alzner just on MTL)

For the most part I agree, at the moment I think Doughty can make his look good but otherwise I have to agree with everyone on this list. If we future this list then I can Doughty going on the list. Also Petry has been fairly solid for the Canadiens. Tyler Myers would be a better addition.

Only thing with Lee and Bob is that Bob is older and it looks like he is on theh downfall, and with the Lee vs Skinner I have to admit a little bit of bias due to the leafs Isles rivarly. But I love it so ya

No way doughty belongs on this list after one off year

Again I really like Doughty but this past year was brutal and based off the ONE year, not his whole career he deserves to be here. After the ONE year, he is not worth the contract. I will gladly eat my words if/when he becomes a top 3 in the Norris again but from what I saw last year he deserves it

Ryan Suter? Really?

Not worth the contract he was given

How so? He’s been a machine and worth every penny.

Yeah, the last few years of that Bob contract are going to be rough, but it's fine rn

Petry definetely shouldnt be on this. Also, Ladd, Clutterbuck and Komarov contracts are worse than Martin