Vancouver laughs, hangs up, and blocks your number

That bad, eh? Greenway and Gaudette's numbers are very similar and they're the same age so I didn't think it was too far off. Guess I misjudged

I don't like the Van trade at all. We already have a Gaudette with Donato. Are you trying to get Rask into the lineup as the 3C/4C?

Why trade Menell for LD version of Menell that can be a UFA in after 1 more year in college?

Just because a guys numbers don't look good doesn't mean he is bad. Greenway is a great defensive player. They may reject but your making it seem horrible


What would be the cost of greenway from the leafs perspective?

We have too many RD prospects, need a LD hence the swap. Gaudette is a young right shot center and scored 33 points in 59 games playing 12 minutes a night and didn't have great linemates. I'd like to see what he could do with more of an opportunity.

Probably something around Kapanen. He's the only player that really fills a need (right shot forward) that's even in the same ballpark as Greenway (I think the Wild add for the record)

VAN decline, Gaudette is still getting better and is a core piece for the Canucks.

That's fair!

It's a little bit of everything really, Gaudette did have more points while playing in 10ish less games he's also a center while Greenway is a winger which gives him more value, also Rathbone is 2 years younger than Mennel and is coming off a season where he was above a point per game in college.

They clearly value him as a 2nd line center plus Rathbone has a chance to become a legit top 4 defensemen so why would the Canucks trade all that for a bottom 6 winger and an undrafted AHL defensemen

Menell was in contention for AHL defenseman of the year, I'd rather not get rid of him for a left d. Kinda wanna see what the draft brings.

Look closer. 12 of those points were on the PP and he had heavy o-zone useage. Take away the PP stats and he's on par with Donato and Hartman, who also limited ToI and not great linemates.

WPG laughs and says yes....jk...I think that's fair but I would think that they would rather have Stastny

Not a bad proposal. Jets I think take the deal.
Vancouver would not. As someone else said Gaudette has more value than Greenway because of position and point potential. Van would prob want a C back. But as @wabit said, Donato is kind of a similar player to Gaudette, I'd say Donato may be a bit ahead on the defensive side while Gaudette on the offensive said.
Rathbone is similar to what the wild have in Calen Addison. The Canucks already have a Menell in Rafferty who is RD and was AHL rookie dman for the year I believe.