No, too much retention. If you want retention, the offer is Kap and a 2nd for Murphy (1,000,000 retained) and a 3rd

I thought you meant McDavid

Thats what i was going for lol. Had to give Bracco to EDM to show there was a oilers trade....

Retention is a bit much but Murphy for Kapanen is fair, generally speaking

Hawks aren't retaining that much. Understand retaining $650k to make the cap hits a wash, but not a chance hawks retain that much unless Leafs give up something substantial

What would something substantial be?

no team is gonna pay a fifth for bracco

Going to cost Kap plus a 2nd or Dermott

Would you be okay with
Kap, Dermott, 2nd
For
Murphy, (1,000,000 Retained), Nylander, 4th?

No, Hawks aren't moving Nylander for a Dermott (let alone adding a 4th) which is what you're proposing. Hawks would move Nylander and a 4th for Kap maybe but the Hawks see a big future for Nylander. However, besides moving cap space, that doesn't get you defense so not sure that makes sense.

Hawks don't need Dermott, we would likely flip him (Hawks are loaded on LHD with Keith, Maatta, De Haan, Carlsson, Beaudin and Vlasic to name a few)....just saying that a 2nd round pick or Dermott is the value if you expect the Hawks to retain big money on Murphy in a Murphy for Kap trade.

Gotcha. Just thought it’d be cool to have brothers on a team

buddy its a joke