Quoting: palhal
Some Sabres think Hall is getting way more than you offered and not have to retain also. IMO there aren't going to that many offers for Hall. So your offers in the ballpark.
But I would give Sabres Poulin...a true future and a second, and make the Montreal trade Denault for Dumoulin. As suggested Habs don't want to weaken their team during a Cup run an Dumoulin could be just what the Habs need.
Yeah, that's why I suggested the possibility of throwing in additional prospects. Penguins took two goalies relatively high last year, which Buffalo could be interested in.
I agree that about your point with Hall. Not many teams with cap space or contenders willing to part way with roster players. Look at Colorado's roster for example, who would they send back to match the salary? They already have Saad as basically a rental.
Your point about Dumoulin to Montreal is interesting. He would most likely be their top LD and push a guy like Edmundson out of the lineup, making them better. On the other hand, they already have a bit of a logjam at that position, which has pushed Kulak and Mete out of the lineup at times.
If they are interested at that upgrade (and make a corresponding move to trade one of the other LD), I think your counterproposal makes a lot of sense.