Matthews is really good... Marchand and Spurgeon as well imo

The leafs hate

Go check out my list, it's much better

dont forget Hamilton and Muzzin (defensive monster) and Kapenan (guy literally is the definition of puck luck)

also how is Sandin overrated lul. Kids a stud and has been called a steal in his draft class.

Only guy I see on the list who is truly overrated IMO (funny it is actually a Leaf as well) is Holl. Some Leafs fans like to try to sell him Kerfoot and Engvall as if they are superstar 1st line players. How many Kerfoot + Engvall + Hollander + pick trades have we seen for the likes Hall of Eichel or Gaudreau? Don't get me wrong he is a useful bottom pair D man much like Kulak. A guy I wouldn't mind having on the Habs 3rd pairing RHD but not a guy worth more than a 4th, 3trd tops.

I mean I’ve seen some terrible Leafs trades on here but never for Eichel or Gaudreau. Hall most definitely but that’s only because his stock is so low right now.

Absolutely agree Holl is very overrated. Very useful NHL player but realistically a 6-7 on most teams with a already good top 4.

This list is terrible

It was pretty funny when people were posting Holls RAPM chart after the first 2 weeks of the season and actually thinking he would maintain a Norris caliber impact. Lol - I like holl , definitely overrated but solid 3rd pairing guy who should be useful in the playoffs.

He is very effective on the LEAFS! But that’s it. He is propped up by playing with Muzzin and again on any other team that has a solid top 4, he would more than likely be battling to keep his spot.

Malkin is 100% going to be in the hall of fame. How can he possibly be overrated?

True - there aren’t many two way D as good as Muzzin. Guys like him, gryzeleck, Devon toews, weegar can make their D partners look better than they are.

I’ll never understand, IF rumours were true, that Dubas did not want to trade Johnsson + Dermott for Weegar.

Grez, Towes (lighting it up in COL), both very good.

lol, look at the salty Habs fan.

Ahh, leafs hater I see.
Everyone has their own opinions, but it's unfair to put 8 leafs up here. Personally I would argue that none of them are overrated, but that is debatable.

Hahah seriously... also doesn’t playing behind Sid make him fall slip thru the cracks at times? Like I feel like forever everyone talked Crosby (rightfully so) and Malkin would have 90 + points. A couple of really odd choices. I guess it’s all a matter of opinion