Formenton wipes them all I fear

Hedman underrated, Crosby overrated.

Matthews should be 3rd ahead of MacKinnon.

Otherwise it's decent

Is this, "top-10 in skating ability"...or, "top-10 non-goalies"?

Non goalies

Best skating ability...

McDavid
Jack Hughes
Makar
Quinn Hughes
Panarin
Kuznetsov
Crosby
Larkin
Barzal
Hall
Ehlers
MacKinnon
Duchene
Josi
Spurgeon
Marner

Crosby overrated? Holy Christ I didn’t know people got drunk this early

Skater=non goalie.

Got it. Will make "skating" ACGM

I meant like at this point in his career, he's obviously one of the greatest players of all time. I could be wrong but I just don't see him as a top 10 player in the league anymore, not above guys like Kaprizov and Gaudreau at least

1 McDavid
2 Makar
3 Matthews
4 Mackinnon (seriously what’s with the M’s?)
5 Kucherov
6 Hedman
7 Josi
8 Drai
9 Barkov
10 Crosby

Fox is just outside a top 10. He definitely makes a top 15.

Others just outside:

Gaudreau
Huberdeau
Ovi
Marchand
Fox
McAvoy
Stamkos
Kaprizov
Miller
Panarin

He’s easily above Kaprizov

For me kuch drai matthews and mackinnon are all pretty interchangeable

Kuch is a bit behind and Matthews is a bit ahead IMO, but they're not too different. McDavid is easily on top tho

That’s fair I just love the fact kucherov goes absolute beast mode in playoffs

same, when it comes to playoffs Kuchy is astonishing

Compared to the fan survey that JFresh just conducted on twitter, this is how your list compares

McDavid -
Makar-
MacKinnon +1
Kucherov +2
Matthews -2
Draisaitl +1
Fox +2
Barkov +13
Crosby +4
Hedman -5

Kaprisov at 10 and Josi at 8 were the two differences between the fan survey and your list.

I think yours is certainly closer to where Barkov should be ranked, but I think I'd have him just outside the top 10. Same goes for Crosby these days and being just outside the top 10.

One that stands out for me with that is how criminally underrated barkov is, I can live with outside top ten, but not in top 20????