This is only just the framework of this trade, but this would be a good move for both teams. The Isles clear up a C spot for Horvat and clear out cap, and the Canes add a middle 6 C who would be an excellent fit for the defensive system. This proposal would be for acquiring JGP without retention.

As it stands, the Isles aren’t in a great position in a couple of areas. As I touched on, they are overloaded at C with the Horvat addition, close to the cap, and aren’t in the greatest of spots for a chance at the playoffs (good but not great). JGP could return assets, whereas for Bailey an argument could be made that the Isles would have to pay to move. A move like this also helps clear up cap for Horvat assuming he wants to resign.

How far off on value is this and what needs to be changed?

Mantha seems to have fallen out of favor with the Caps, and with the Caps trying for what could be their final chance at the cup for a while, they will need cap space at swing for the fences. The Canes love their reclamation projects, and Mantha could end up finding his game with a change of scenery. With Patches now on LTIR, I am expecting the Canes to make a move soon, but a move that few people would expect would be this. I don’t see the Caps getting much for Mantha though, but I could see a team paying for the retention aspect.

How far off is this proposal? Mantha is a bit tricky considering I’ve heard quite a few fans saying he is more of a dump, while others have said he is still very worth a lot. As I currently see it, he is about a 50 point winger who has never hit his true potential. Under the right coach he could finally find his stride.