Jesus I thought you were gonna trade Crosby lol

Pens don't need a shake-up, they need to improve their PP. They are a top 5 team 5v5.

Hawks probably decline. Take out the pick back to the Pens and maybe the Hawks consider it. Just don't see them trading Raddysh for a 4th liner and a pick swap.

Guentzel alone is worth more than that package from the Stars, but you want to throw Pettersson in there too?

You clearly don't want the Pens to commit to a full rebuild, but at the same time want to trade two of the best players on this team for a borderline insulting return?

Lmao get a grip.

You do realize how good Maverick Bourque is, right?

I wouldn't put it past this guy. He's shown time and time again his brain is just a slab of concrete.

If it doesn't make the team better right now, it doesn't matter.

Going to be hard to get players from a contender. I could SEA being interested because they want a goal scorer -- maybe a Tolvinen Weinberg pick for Guentzel swap?

Who watches Pens games and thinks we'd be better off without Guentzel?

How much overlap is there between him being a top of the lineup NHL contributor and Crosby/Malkin/Letang/Karlsson being top of the lineup contributors though?

Penguins need to be treating every season those four guys are playing well like it's going to be the last, because there's a good chance it is. Can't swap Guentzel's roster spot for Marchment's roster spot on the basis of "well Mavrick Borque might play on our top line in two years" because who knows what this lineup looks like in two years?

In other words: