SalarySwishSalarySwish
Avatar

TooMalevolent

Member Since
Jul. 4, 2017
Forum Posts
1576
Posts per Day
0.6
Forum: Armchair-GMMay 17, 2022 at 2:37 p.m.
Thread: Winnipeg Toronto Swap
<div class="quote"><div class="quote_t">Quoting: <b>TooMalevolent</b></div><div>They are such a fascinating team. Do they retool to compete instantly, or are they alright with one more non-playoff year? If they are doing the latter, do you trade the goalie? If you do is his value lower now? Are you risking trading a guy that before this year was elite?

I hope whatever they do, they don't go small either way. I read rumors about how randy carlyle might be someone they are interested in for coaching. I don't know about that. I want to see them go after someone big, and improve the other staff. I think it's best to trade Schiefele and Wheeler, but I think Wheeler is highly unlikely. If they could trade a Schiefele + and bring back a dman, or a two-way forward, that would be ideal. Hope they play the young guys, but I think it's imperative they bring them along well and the right way. I get these things wrong like everyone else (I thought Sam Bennett was going to be a stud), but I think Perfetti is a star. But he can't be a player that completely disregards his own end.</div></div>

100%
It would be a tough decision, these upcoming drafts are stacked. So as a management team you'd want to make a commitment in either direction, nothing half-assed.
You either rebuild and focus on youth or you push to remain a contender. In terms of Perfetti... he IS and WILL be a star. His defensive impacts are actually fantastic (92% percentile). Will be a fun player to watch for years to come.

Trading Scheifele may actually make your team instantly better, which is hard to believe. His defensive impacts are the worst in the league (0% percentile). He reminds me of the kids you used to play with as a kid in the higher levels that you just hated to have on your team.

Either way, with all that said you have a chance at a bounce back season and still contend OR you blow it up and stock up in these top tier drafts.
Forum: Armchair-GMMay 17, 2022 at 1:07 p.m.
Thread: Winnipeg Toronto Swap
<div class="quote"><div class="quote_t">Quoting: <b>TooMalevolent</b></div><div>What's your thoughts on trading him? Honestly as an outsider I'll tell you I am very anti Schiefele. He's a good player no doubt, especially offensively, but I find he is awful defensively. I'm also not a guy that goes for the whole "you have to be on all the time" bit (I don't think most players are Sid Crosby), but I think I dislike and critique Schiefele for his lack of engagement and back-checking more than others because he seems to have this rep that he does those things, and I very much don't think he does. And I hated his comments after the season. I would never have the temperament to be a GM because I would have traded him instantly for just that presser.

But it's also tough. I thought PLD was a shoe-in to sign, but it appears that may not happen? So maybe you are left with this thing where you have to trade him. And then maybe keeping a guy that has committed and seems okay playing in that city is better.</div></div>
If I was the GM of Winnipeg he would be shipped. He's legit the worst defensive forward in the entire league (0% D-percentile). I think if you guys free up that cap space, get that mentality out of the locker room it may be the only real move you need to make.

Winnipeg is a great team and likely just an off year.
Forum: Armchair-GMMay 17, 2022 at 1:55 p.m.
Thread: Winnipeg Toronto Swap
<div class="quote"><div class="quote_t">Quoting: <b>hockey_mike91</b></div><div>Well that's the fun of being an Armchair GM, whether the media is saying it or a group of fans. Good entertainment!

I agree Muzzin isn't going anywhere. He wouldn't waive and at the end of the day he's actually very good. The issue will be health moving forward.

I don't think LA in general makes sense as a trade partner anymore, you guys are already now coming out of the rebuild and got some great young pieces. Fun team to watch over the next 3 years and beyond.

I know we're going to have nightmares about Durzi lol</div></div>

Agree with pretty much all of what you just said.

The cool thing about the LA-Toronto trades is that they seem to have worked out for both teams equally well. No, the Leafs haven't won past the 1st round, but they've still been incredibly successful otherwise. Campbell has turned into a heck of a goalie, Muzz was great for you for the past few years, and even Clifford had his parts to play.

On the flip side, LA is sitting pretty with Moore, Durzi, Grundstrom, and Bjornfot.
Forum: Armchair-GMMay 17, 2022 at 2:12 p.m.
Thread: Winnipeg Toronto Swap
<div class="quote"><div class="quote_t">Quoting: <b>PuckLuck_77</b></div><div>Agree with pretty much all of what you just said.

The cool thing about the LA-Toronto trades is that they seem to have worked out for both teams equally well. No, the Leafs haven't won past the 1st round, but they've still been incredibly successful otherwise. Campbell has turned into a heck of a goalie, Muzz was great for you for the past few years, and even Clifford had his parts to play.

On the flip side, LA is sitting pretty with Moore, Durzi, Grundstrom, and Bjornfot.</div></div>

Completely agree with you! It's good when it works out for both parties (especially in different conferences)

I'm a huge Leafs fan (born into it), but absolutely love the Kings. You got one of my hometown kids in Byfield, he was a rockstar player growing up here in minor hockey.
Forum: Armchair-GMMay 17, 2022 at 1:04 p.m.
Forum: Armchair-GMMay 17, 2022 at 1:13 p.m.
Thread: Winnipeg Toronto Swap
<div class="quote"><div class="quote_t">Quoting: <b>TooMalevolent</b></div><div>What's your thoughts on trading him? Honestly as an outsider I'll tell you I am very anti Schiefele. He's a good player no doubt, especially offensively, but I find he is awful defensively. I'm also not a guy that goes for the whole "you have to be on all the time" bit (I don't think most players are Sid Crosby), but I think I dislike and critique Schiefele for his lack of engagement and back-checking more than others because he seems to have this rep that he does those things, and I very much don't think he does. And I hated his comments after the season. I would never have the temperament to be a GM because I would have traded him instantly for just that presser.

But it's also tough. I thought PLD was a shoe-in to sign, but it appears that may not happen? So maybe you are left with this thing where you have to trade him. And then maybe keeping a guy that has committed and seems okay playing in that city is better.</div></div>

I'm very much on the fence. On one side, I see the reports that say how bad he is in the dressing room, and see his lack of effort on the defensive side of the puck. He's also so whinny to officials which is something else I can't stand. Also, if he doesn't wanna be here, than they may as well move on from him.

But on the other side, top line centers don't grow on trees. He's a very good player, and having your top 3 up the middle as Schiefele, Dubios &amp; Lowry is very solid IMO (maybe I'm bias as a fan lol)

But yeah that's another issue too, really hope Dubios signs here!
Forum: Armchair-GMMay 17, 2022 at 12:13 p.m.
Thread: Winnipeg Toronto Swap
<div class="quote"><div class="quote_t">Quoting: <b>TooMalevolent</b></div><div>If he's elite level like he was before this season, honestly return should be massive. If I was the Jets I would ask for 1st, Knies, Niemela. And I think I might be well low on it. This is a guy that when he was at his best, I don't think there was a goalie better. You saw how the Jets imploded because he had an average year. That's how bad that team is defensively- if their goalie is not the best in the world they are dreadful.</div></div>

I agree with you, that's the gamble for both parties.

In reality, he does likely bounce back to elite form and I think both teams management would agree. I think it would take a haul as well.

1st, Knies, Niemela feels steep from a "Leafs" bias but you're right that it's likely a starting point.
Forum: Armchair-GMMar. 17, 2022 at 10:57 a.m.