Or any sane hockey fan. It’s not even close

You think CBJ fans are bad? Look at Carolina fans when you make any trade for Pesce

I get you hate the Leafs but try too look at this objectively!

As a carolina fan, and a HUGE Pesce fan, I can Honestly say......

Seth Jones IMO, is easily one of the top 3 best RD in the league......
And with the contract he is on, I would take him over any other RD.........except maybe Pesce

Without knowing who Paul Bittner is I think that's a pretty decent trade for Columbus.

Oh boy, a Toronto fan saying another team overrates their players lmao never forget the Luke Schenn is worth Eric Staal talk from Leafs fans

He's a throw in

And when did I say any of that???

No, definitely not all? just sum.

Thats almost as bad as the Brett Pesce is worth Mitch Marner talk from Hurricanes fans

Or the Kadri is worth Pesce talk from Leafs fans

Yeah, except no one said that ever........Actually i would not want Marner in Carolina at 11.5 mil per season. I would rather have Nylander

In all fairness Kadri got the Leafs Barrie and Kerfoot which is a better return than just Pesce

That trade would be fair if you too Dubinsky back in the trade, but sadly that wouldn’t happen, just like this trade. It’s a good try but Jones isn’t going anywhere for a while. Good try though.

The problem is Jones is one of the best 3 RHD and is on a great contract. What Toronto is offering is one of the top ten best players at their position?

Nylander is not one of the top ten wingers.
Barrie is not one of the top ten defenseman in the league
Sandin and Liljegren are prospects and unproven
Bracco is another prospect and he has played in the NHL but is also a prospect.
The 1st is going to be in the 20's or possibly the 30's.

If you want to get Jones quantity of prospects, low picks and names that are not even in the top 15 players at their position do not get Jones and Anderson.

I do not have a Leaf bias just do not see Columbus doing this deal.

Dude, come on. This is absurd. Seth Jones is a top five nhl d man on an unreal contract. Zero motivation for his team to move him, and here we have him moving with an awesome big bodied 27 goal scorer with grit on a contract under 2 million, for a barrel of question marks in nylander, two solid prospects and a second. Why would the blue jackets ever do this? It’s a horrible deal for them.

I think the league is better when the leafs are good. This trade would get rejected in nhl19 on easy mode.

A trade for Seth Jones starts with Marner and needs more. Forget about Anderson. What a joke that you thought this was close, and it seems like you thought the jackets were getting the better of it

Dude, I know how good Seth Jones is as I've followed him as much as I could) with the Portland winter hawks all the way to the NHL when he was projected too go first overall (well there was a connection as his dad played for the Nuggets) and he fell to 4th overall (to Nashville). Thats why i love baseball as they always go by the bigger sample size. Also did you not see Berrie in there! Also how do you think he's (Seth Jones) gonna react too losing for two years, when he can become a free agent the following year? Like I said before Dubois, and Werenski should be there building blocks of the future. Move him now or in the future for leds return as his contract wont be a sweetheart deal anymore. Also he will be 28 to start a new contract. Anderson on a real playoff team is a 3rd liner who can fill in on the second line and yes I know all about him too as he's a local boy). I swapped out Marner for Nylander because the difference is more than made up. Also I see you hating on more Leafs threads than your on Boston threads and your handle gives it away. Anyways Nylander, Wennberg and Borkstrand would make o e of the deadliest lines in the league, plus i would assume they'd flip Berrie for more future's. Point is they can do it now or wait untill his value is down ie contract and age, as they cant let him go into gis walk year without a extension.

Id, accept Dubinsky for Ceci! You get outta the contract a Year earlier and save $$.

And fair enough, I can totally respect your opinion! at least your open minded?

so, help break it down for me .... who goes for whom ? Just so I have a clear picture.

We send Nylander, Berrie, Liligren, Sandin and Bracco plus a 1st for Jones, Anderson, Bittner and a 3rd. Both picks in 2022.

lol I get that but is Barrie straight up for Jones ? OR is it Barrie +1st for jones, Nylander for Anderson, Sandin, braco and lilegren for bitter and 3rd ?

Nylander,Liligren,Sandin and Berrie for Jones, Bracco and the 1st for Anderson,Bittner and a 3rd. Overpay? I know but Jones and Reilly would be the best Dpairng in the league! A Columbus fan said to add Dubinsky, for which I said swap out Berrie for Ceci then. Would be fair considering the trade market for Jonesif he was made available). What do you think?

I think it is over payment but honestly I wish I had a better understanding of their depth to say if it was good or not .... I mean Nylander and Barrie for Jones is very lop sided, especially when you throw in a few kids too

I know, i just wanted to shut them up... Well most of them some are actually realistic. But its Seth Freakin Jones man. I would do that deal all day everyday Reilly and Jones would be the best pairing in the league hands down.