Edmundson is worth a 1st at trade deadline. Yamamoto isn't worth a 1st.

brother what makes you think a 3LD making 1 mil too much is worth a 2nd round pick let alone a first...?

Ben Chariot makes every Habs fan think a big dman can get a 1st

Montreal doesn't take this deal because they have a log jam of forwards already. They need to clear a contract or two by dealing for picks, not for players

Ok bro, here's how it works: you can make an offer but we can say no. If you believe what is asked is too much, you can simply walk. Now if you're desperate to improve your D then let's talk.

You have a roster of 21 players and $13K in cap space. You're a price taker, not a price maker.

In essence, this is what is called a short squeeze.

Because Edmundson have WAY MORE value than Chiarot, and Habs will likely ask a 1st round pick minimum.

Are you really trying to make the hockey world have an aneurism? Montreal isn’t going to take that.

You give me Chiarot PTSD.

Not gonna argue with a guy that havent seen Edmundson played in years and can't educate himself with comparables.

You've got the wrong impression of Edmundson, he's 2nd pair defensive defenceman

Chiarot was traded for a 1st at last TDL. Same type of defenseman, same salary, same value.