Lenny7
Joined: Jan. 2017
Posts: 13,291
Likes: 11,051
I'm curious as to what you mean by "Raty has had on ice issues since being drafted but has turned that around this year"? Like, he was bad in his draft year, so he slipped to the 2nd round, but then all of the sudden in a different situation the next year he was good again? Because I'm not sure how that could possibly affect his value to anything close to a guy that remains ineligible to play in the NHL...
Aside from that, the Horvat trade is not a comparable. The Isles traded for 30+ games of him, with no extension in place, but managed to lock him up long term. You're getting a full season.