Quoting: Terry_AkiSauce
Honestly, I agree about the Campbell contract being atrocious but they're getting a lot back. I could see the 3rd being swapped for Bourgault but I don't wanna hear that he's worth more since he's an all-star since the system to become one is a joke. He's 7 years into his career with 1ppg season and it was 61 pts in 60 games. TK is probably worth Broberg and a late first (obviously depends on the buyers/sellers but in a fair market). Hart is probably worth a first and a 3rd and that's solely based on name value at this point. I'm not the biggest believer in GSAA but his is negative over his career, I do believe he's a top 25 goalie though he hasn't had much of an opportunity to prove it over an extended period of time. So, we're at the return here minus Campbell for the two players, could something be added? Absolutely, but this certainly isn't a terrible package
Its not a terrible package by any means, I would add Bourgault though. My biggest detractor is always Campbell. I do agree that the All-Star title doesn't really add much value, its kind of just a bragging right more than anything. I don't see Edmonton needing to add all of their picks and prospects for this.
Logistically speaking I would say a base of TK for Broberg + 2023 1st and a 2nd. Feel free for either team to manipulate it.
Hart is a much more complex case given standings, non-stat based value on potential, and timeline placement. If he weren't such a complex cog I would say he'd fetch a 1st and Bourgault and another B+ level prospect.
These are all bases I expect to increase in value based on other teams bids and possible desperations.
If I was Edmonton I'd focus on more of a pursuit of a defensive upgrade. I don't think they should give up on Skinner after one bad playoff performance.