Quoting: JSEB93
To be fair, Desmith played for a worse team this past season though and put up significantly better numbers. Desmith has had terrible defensive play in front of him for years. 2 better years maybe - 3 is a definite no for me. But those 2 better years were 4 and 5 years ago. If you want to take a risk that's fine - I don't think this team is in a position to be taking fliers on players hopefully bouncing back. Maybe that's just me - that could just be personal preference. It's not just the AAV though - you're giving up assets for him too. I'm not trying to crap on your team or anything haha - I just think you have a downgrade at the goalie position and you gave up assets to do so. That's the way I'm looking at it.
The options for improvement over Jarry are slim sure - but I would say there's a decent amount of options that would be an improvement over this. Jarry, Anderson, Varlamov are definitely better. The you got Korpisalo and probably Hill would also be better. Could trade for Hellebuyck, Ullmark, or Samsonov. Gibson is definitely out of the questions - I wouldn't say Hellebuyck is though. Even at like 2mil I still think you're better off just keeping Desmith than trading for Blackwood - unless you got a top tier starter like Hellebuyck or Ullmark. Then having Blackwood wouldn't bother me as much.
Getting better depth up front would be a big help - and could alleviate the goaltending worries as well. If Carter is still the 3C this team is in big trouble - unless he has 2 fantastic wingers around him. To me I just think it's a downgrade in net, and no real improvement at forward(specifically the 3rd line). You brought in Graves which is nice so the defense should be better - but that means at best I see this team being equal to last season overall.
Andersen would most likely cost more than both Goalies I proposed put together, Varlamov and Korpisalo could work. No chance they get Hellebuyck or Gibson unless they decide that to have ZERO prospects and Picks of which they are already low. Samsonov would cost close to a 1st rounder, so would Ullmark.
The Hill hype train is ridiculous, the guy played well on a good team but, Quick, Brossoit and Thompson play and they win anyway. Taking him makes less sense than Blackwood IMO.
That 3rd season I talk about Blackwood's stats might be worse than DeSmith but, NJD was ranked 13th in the conference and Pitt was Top 5, so I'd argue 3 for sure and his 3 bad years since have been injured and hard to build consistency.
Again the goaltending is up for debate, I just went with a young-ish Goalie and a Vet that can split time. If a goalie like Martin Jones can have a bounce back season so could Blackwood and Fleury.
I also have no faith in DeSmith since he lost me money every time he played and I bet on Pitt lol.