Have you watched Saros? He’s the only thing keeping Nashville anywhere near playoff contention

I have a myriad of quibbles with this, but that’s the most obvious.

Saros is no doubt top 5 at the worst

Demko > Bobrovsky, Hill, Gustavsson for sure. I’d also take him over Swayman, Georgiev, and maybe Oettinger

You're definitely an east coast fan

Demko way to low

Bobrovsky Gsaa -.7
Save % 899
But you have him 12???
There are better backups in the league than him! Like his!!!

Varlamov 3 spaces too low

The east coast glazing is crazy

After top 5-8 guys…it’s really hard to order the rest of them. Age, health and contract become more determinative.

(Separately…would an interesting list to rank #2’s. Few guys are regular 60-70 start goalies anymore)

Everything after 7 or so is probably a crapshoot on how they'll do in any particular year

vejmelka is 1.85GAA and .942 SV - early on but 4 games (3 against playoff teams)

Definitely those first 3 but I don’t know about those other 3 maybe georgiev but that’s it

Last 3 seasons
5v5:
Demko: 20/21: .925 SV%, 6.67 GSAA, 7.89 GSAx
21/22: .933 SV%, 26.42 GSAA, 19.81 GSAx
22/23: .920 SV%, 4.43 GSAA, 7.14 GSAx
22/23 after return from injury: .930 SV%, 7.72 GSAA, 8.22 GSAx

Oettinger: 20/21: .923 SV%, 3.21 GSAA, 0.32 GSAx
21/22: .918 SV%, 2.3 GSAA, 1.13 GSAx
22/23: .925 SV%, 14.79 GSAA, 12.71 GSAx

Georgiev: 20/21: .917 SV%, -0.32 GSAA, -4.22 GSAx
21/22: .915 SV%, -0.85 GSAA, 0.87 GSAx
22/23: .929 SV%, 21.43 GSAA, 12.6 GSAx

Swayman: 20/21 (10 games): .951 SV%, 7.23 GSAA, 4.31 GSAx
21/22: .921 SV%, 4.33 GSAA, -3.66 GSAx
22/23: .930 SV%, 10.81 GSAA, 16.21 GSAx

All situations:
Demko: 20/21: .915 SV%, 8.03 GSAA, 8.7 GSAx
21/22: .915 SV%, 15.01 GSAA, 7.3 GSAx
22/23 When Healthy: .918 SV%, -1.92 GSAA, 9.86 GSAx

Oettinger: 20/21: .911 SV%, 2.97 GSAA, -2.14 GSAx
21/22: .914 SV%, 7.61 GSAA, 0.51 GSAx
22/23: .919 SV%, 23.59 GSAA, 21.65 GSAx

Georgiev: 20/21: .905 SV%, -1.3 GSAA, -3.1 GSAx
21/22: .898 SV%, -6.74 GSAA, 5.3 GSAx
22/23: .918 SV%, 24.08 GSAA, 17.29 GSAx

Swayman: 20/21 (10 games): .945 SV%, 9.47 GSAA, 4.83 GSAx
21/22: .914 SV%, 6.21 GSAA, -4.31 GSAx
22/23: .920 SV%, 14.06 GSAA, 20.99 GSAx

Could definitely put Demko above Oettinger and Swayman

These stats prove he’s better then oettinger but not swayman