Quoting: LikeABoss
From the little bit I saw, I can't see him in an offensive D role in the NHL, hopefully I'm wrong, but I just don't think he sees the game at that level. You might say well that's why they teach and develop, but I'd point out that jocks aren't typically stereotyped as quick learners. I'm not a fan of your top 5 blueline cuz I don't agree the league is going that way. Who's the last cup champion that had only 1 D-man who hits on the blueline? Expand that to cup finalists or even conference finalists if you'd like, I'm just curious to see your work on that one.
I don't disagree with you on the size thing, I think he covers a lot of ice more because he skates really well and happens to have a longer stick, but he doesn't play "big" though. I'd say it's definately worth a shot putting him out there with Seider if he ever makes the big club, but he is definitely still a project. Don't get me wrong though his skating is very tantalizing, if they can get him to improve his anticipation and decision making I could see that high of a ceiling for him.
Wallinder could not pan out, I wouldn’t bet on it, but it’s possible. A bunch of people were calling for Raymond’s head prior to this season, and he put in the work to which results have been showing. Cossa/Kasper still look to be in the “can it translate” conversation. That’s the risk with all prospects.
As far as the stereotype, couldn’t be further from reality lol. Take a look at college athlete gpas, unless you mean major junior players. Now I will concede there are some lemons that play and unfortunately that’s part of every profession.
I also agree physicality is needed. I think Yzerman addressed that with a bunch of his other defensive draft picks(Cleveland), as well as bringing in heavier players (Kostin, Fish). No reason to think he won’t find similar players to add around the talent.
With Mo being physical, and not a “natural” offensive player, blended with Wallinder gives 2, 6’4 rangy D that could do a little bit of everything (assuming Mo keeps getting better). Mo is more physical and WW more transitional, stick check, offense.
Edvinsson seems like a 2-way guy at the NHL level, blended with ASP’s smaller stature and offensive gifts looks very interesting.
Walman blew away my expectations. He has easily been Detroit’s best D this season, and at the slightly older age is becoming a seasoned vet. Plays mean, plays fun, both sides of the puck, goes after stars.
It probably won’t be the top 5, as the NHL is ever changing, but personally I like the look of it. Just like you like Ferraro. Nothing wrong with that.