I would say like Mitch and kappy not Mitch and Willy also no salary retained

Marner, Sandin and a pick for Eichel

I'd do that in a heartbeat.

I don't understand the obsession of overpaying Tanev on this site.

I think he going to get a raise on his 4.5 mill so 5 x 5 is probably what he will get on the open market

Yeah, I think he will get close to that. He shouldn't, but probably will.

Make it stop

You must be out of your mind to trade Marner. Have no idea what you are thinking as Eichel has no interest in playing on a Canadian based team.

Remember when leaf fans thought Marner was better than Eichel?

The diffrence between Eichel and Marner is more than Sandin.Sandin show big problems to defend against NHL Players.Yes he very young and a big talent,but its to early to get him big value.

That's just wrong



No... I think you're confusing him with Matthews.



He was only 19. He's gonna be a top 4 D or better.

I mean he wanted badly to be selected by the Oilers in the draft. In case you didn't know, Edmonton is in Canada.

Would you do Matthews for Reinhart, Jokiharju, Mittelstadt, and Kahun?

That would be like me switching out Marner for Kapanen. Reinhart isn't even as good as Nylander.

Oh, just realized you're the guy who though Leafs would buy out Boychuk for over 10 million dollars to trade Johnsson for Mayfield.

Well since you want to bring up irrelevant topics lets do some fact checking if you are going to address me as "That guy who said this..." as an excuse to disregard my opinion
- First Boychuk is owed a total of 8M over the last 2 seasons of his contract, if bought out that would be 2/3 of his remaining contract over 4 years. So Toronto would owe Boychuk 5.33M (odd how that's just over half of the above stated 10M.
- Second, in 13/14 the league nixed a trade between Toronto and Tampa where Toronto would CBO Lecavalier and Tampa would resign him for less. If this trade went through Lecavalier still was owed 45M on his contract. Multiply that by 2/3 and a you get 30M.
- Third Mayfield not only fills a hole in the Leafs roster, he is cheap, has term, can play heavy minutes, and is defensively strong. Moving Johnsson for Mayfield is a win for Toronto and only an idiot would think otherwise
So tell me why Toronto has no issue spending 30m on a player not even playing for them for a couple picks yet wouldn't spend 5.33M on a player also not playing for them while upgrading their roster in the process.

Now back to the actual topic:
Is Marner better then Reinhart? Duh, Reinhart is a little below Nylander in skill
Sandin vs Jokiharju? About even in ceiling, Joker is RD and both have top pair potential.
Mittelstadt vs Kerfoot? With Kerfoot you have a bonafide 3C with Mittelstadt you have the potential of a 2C still there. Edge Mittelstadt
Kahun vs Johnsson? Every statistic says Kahun is all around better. You could argue he played with Malkin but Johnsson played with Matthews, so that goes no where.

Well i would, but im guessing that was your point.