Joined: Jul. 2020
Posts: 1,021
Likes: 641
The Detroit trade is a little silly. The two players hold little value in all honesty, theyre not old, but theyre not prospects anymore, and won't become impact pieces.
A 2nd from the oilers should be in the 50s, and a 3rd should be in the 80s.
2AHL players plus a late 2nd and late 3rd does not relieve you of Neal's contract imo.
The Staal trade got Detroit the 45th pick, for a player who played a position of need capably, for one year with his $1m signing bonus already paid and a real $salary of $3.2m.
The value for a Neal trade needs to therefore be more than double that as James Neal is paid only salary no bonuses, and is owed $5.75m real dollars in both of the remaining years of his deal. James Neal also does not play a position of need for Detroit, nor does he have the same leadership qualities as Staal. Assuming Edmonton finish in the same position as this year and therefore draft 20th, double the value of the Staal trade would be their 1st at 20th and a 3rd. Because the real dollars are higher the value would need to be better still. And that is assuming that the value of cap space hasnt increased since then, which is likely given our better understanding of the long term cap situation in the league.