Detroit declines

Phi can get a lot more for Hayes with 3 years retention.

That return for Hart feels light honestly not by much but a little

Detroit isn't trading 9OA unless it's part of a bigger trade that moves us into the top 5

That's pick 9; not 17. Islander's pick is #17.

Take out a 3rd or Kubalik and sure.

I am not as high on Hart as some others. I would say that pick 43 should also be going to Ottawa in this situation. If that's the case, I think the deal makes sense for all teams.

But my proposal in this 3 way would be:

To PHI: Pick 17 (islanders), 2023 2nd (DET) (maybe even Detroit 3rd instead)
Out: Carter Hart

To OTT: Berggren, Carter Hart,
Out: ADB

To DET: ADB
Out: Pick 17 (Islanders), 2023 2nd (DET) (maybe even Detroit 3rd instead), Berggren

Flyers add in York, konecny, farabee this year's first 7th overall, next year's first, Foerester and brink to wings deal

So Philly acts as a middle man and somehow get more than Chicago did actually trading the guy

2 things:

1. Cat will return less value than he did last year as he's more expensive and had a down year

2. Most of that value has to go to Ottawa since they already have him.

Yzerman didn't trade Hronek and add a 1st so he good trade it away for pending UFA midget winger. Detroit isn't in compete now mode, they're not trading futures