Edited Nov. 12, 2020 at 11:33 p.m.
I love 34, but like Matthews is not in the same dimension as MacKinnon. It's McDavid/MacKinnon and everybody else.
To avoid bias, I took out the player names and all y'all leaf fans can hopefully see that, as good as #34 is, he's nothing close to MacKinnon
NOW THAT THE THREAD HAS BLOWN UP ----- MATTHEWS IS PLAYER A
First 4 seasons in the NHL (18-22) i.e. (2013-14 to 2016-17 for Mac) and (2016-17 to 19-20 for Matthews)
Player A: 282gp | 18:47 TOI per game | 158g 80a1 48a2 285p | 1007 shots | 1740 CF | 242 blocks | 218 giveaways | 270 takeaways | 105 hits | 391 hits against | 52% on faceoffs (out of 3651) |
Player B: 300gp | 18:21 TOI per game | 75g 77a1 54a2 206p | 929 shots | 1563 CF | 169 blocks | 150 giveaways | 171 takeaways | 202 hits | 338 hits against | 48% on faceoffs (out of 3448) |
Player A (5v5): 282gp | 15:38 TOI per game | 113g 53a1 24a2 190p | 762 shots | 1321 CF | 225 blocks | 192 giveaways | 254 takeaways | 101 hits | 351 hits against | 52% on faceoffs (out of 3370)
Player B (5v5): 300gp | 14:31 TOI per game | 47g 50a1 37a2 134p | 718 shots | 1192 CF | 150 blocks | 103 giveaways | 155 takeaways | 187 hits | 296 hits against | 47% on faceoffs (out of 2786)
Even if we look at their last 2 seasons
Player A: 138gp | 19:47 TOI per game | 84g 42a1 27a2 153p | 541 shots | 951 CF | 120 blocks | 115 giveaways | 135 takeaways | 68 hits | 187 hits against | 54% on faceoffs (out of 1831)
Player B: 151gp | 21:42 TOI per game | 76g 69a1 47a1 192p | 683 shots | 1141 CF | 62 blocks | 117 giveaways | 135 takeaways | 105 hits | 176 hits against | 43% on faceoffs (out of 2023)
Player A: 138gp | 16:15 TOI per game | 55g 28a1 15a2 98p | 387 shots | 698 CF | 109 blocks | 100 giveaways | 126 takeaways | 65 hits | 163 hits against | 54% on faceoffs (out of 1758)
Player B: 151gp | 16:47 TOI per game | 44g 42a1 18a1 104p | 470 shots | 763 CF | 57 blocks | 90 giveaways | 78 takeaways | 93 hits | 149 hits against | 43% on faceoffs (out of 1792)
Ok but what about this last season? Say, their last 82 games, to round things out?
Player A: Last 82gp | 20:45 TOI per game | 52g 22a1 16a2 90p | 352 shots | 612 CF | 69 blocks | 68 giveaways | 88 takeaways | 50 hits | 99 hits against | 55% on faceoffs (out of 1053)
Player B: Last 82gp | 21:42 TOI per game | 41g 39a1 25a1 105p | 318 shots | 657 CF | 37 blocks | 64 giveaways | 46 takeaways | 60 hits | 90 hits against | 43% on faceoffs (out of 1003)
Player A (5v5) Last 82gp | 16:55 TOI per game | 34g 14a1 6a2 54p | 247 shots | 442 CF | 63 blocks | 62 giveaways | 84 takeaways | 48 hits | 86 hits against | 55% on faceoffs (out of 995)
Player B (5v5) Last 82gp | 16:52 TOI per game | 23g 27a1 10a2 60p | 266 shots | 443 CF | 32 blocks | 51 giveaways | 40 takeaways | 52 hits | 77 hits against | 44% on faceoffs (out of 912)
And yeah, I hear you complaining about how their most common linemates compare, so here's this too
Player A's most common linemates last season (19-20) at 5v5
1. 12g 12a 24p in 51 games ***
2. 21g 19a 40p in 68 games *
3. 3g 12a 15p in 43 games *
4. 9g 27a 36p in 59 games **
again - their 5v5 stats
Player B's most common linemates at last season at 5v5
1. 10g 12a 22p in 54 games ***
2. 17g 15a 32p in 58 games *
3. 9g 13a 22p in 42 games **
4. 10g 16a 26p in 42 games *
again - their 5v5 stats
both PRETTY similar
Ok fine, what about
JUST the last season which was a normal, non covid year (2018-2019)?
2018-2019
Player A: 68gp | 18:32 TOI per game | 37g 23a1 13a2 73p | 251 shots | 447 CF | 60 blocks | 67 giveaways | 57 takeaways | 28 hits | 105 hits against | 51% on faceoffs (out of 911)
Player B: 82gp | 22:05 TOI per game | 41g 32a1 26a2 99p | 365 shots | 589 CF | 31 blocks | 64 giveaways | 48 takeaways | 54 hits | 95 hits against | 44% on faceoffs (out of 1183)
And at 5v5?
Player A: 68gp | 15:25 TOI per game | 25g 16a1 10a2 51p | 182 shots | 336 CF | 54 blocks | 56 giveaways | 51 takeaways | 25 hits | 94 hits against | 53% on faceoffs (out of 892)
Player B: 82gp | 17:13 TOI per game | 23g 17a1 9a2 49p | 242 shots | 382 CF | 31 blocks | 48 giveaways | 46 takeaways | 49 hits | 49 hits against | 43% on faceoffs (out of 1039)
hopefully this finally puts to this silly debate to bed. I love #34 but cmon guys. I use analytics to defend Nylander all the time, but you can't say #34 is even close to the player that MacKinnon is