Edited Dec. 5, 2020 at 7:14 a.m.
Nashville (or any team) would never give that up.
Saros is the starter as early as this season
Fabbro is the only young dman that will make the team
Arvidsson is a 30G forward on a great contract
2 1st means the team only continues getting older and the prospect pool weaker
The team with Kane minus RV, Saros, and Fabbro is worse than it is now
Edit: Also compared to the E. Karlsson trade
Ottawa Got
Tierney
Balcers
Demelo
Norris
a 2nd and some conditional 1sts
Tierney at the time (and still) was a 40ish point player. Not a 30G - 60P player on a good deal. He's more equivalent to Kunin then Arvidsson
Balcers is a 5th round pick and has yet to make a NHL impact - Probably closer to Thomas Novak then Luke
DeMelo didn't even get a qualifying offer from SJS that season and ended up signing for league minimum. - Benning at best but probably Allard is closer
Norris is a nice looking piece but has yet to make any NHL impact. - Probably a close comparison would be Tolvanen. All upside if they can reach it.
Then picks
Ottawa got a 1st for Karlsson re-signing in SJ. Since Kane has 3 more seasons i think this would just be a 1st with no conditions.
They also got another 1st and a 2nd
So a closer comparison to the two trades would be: Kunin, Tolvanen, Novak (or similar prospect), Allard (or similar prospect), 2 1st and a 2nd.