Those returns are overly optimistic.

A 1st for Reimer? 🤣

Petry's days of waiving his NTC-NMC are over. He's back home now.

OVERPAY. Avs decline

Extremely

Yzerman may be a wizard, but even he has his limits

Honestly, why stop at a first for Reimer?
Let's take Bouchard, too.

Dreaming a bit here dude

I could see Perron mayyyybe getting a 1st with full retention - he's a grizzled vet, he has a ring, he's still very productive, so yeah, that's not crazy.

The rest is pretty crazy though:

-Ghost only cost the Hurricanes a 3rd rounder at this past year's deadline, and that was with Arizona giving him the most minutes of his career on a team going nowhere. Not sure why you think he gets a significantly higher value here?

-Clearly, Edmonton would have to add *significantly* here to get the mighty James Reimer, seeing as he has a recent history of putting up incredible numbers and a strong history of coming up big in the playoffs.

-The Islanders have Ryan Pulock, Noah Dobson, and Scott Mayfield all playing RD this year. I can't see any reason (barring injury) that they would be targeting another RHD in Petry, much less giving up a 1st for him when he literally was just acquired for a 4th and a post-hype prospect.

-If Sprong keeps up his pace from last year, I could see him getting a good return - he's 26, making $2M, and is coming off a 20-goal season. Not a terrible value here.

-Fischer needs to make a leap above where he's played at to get this kind of return - I think it's more likely he brings back a later pick and a lottery ticket prospect if Detroit moves him and he's still only a 25-30 point guy.

Only if giving term to mediocre vet defensemen can be considered magic

4 1st round picks, Dude you're delusional. And Petry isn't waiving he's a Red Wing at least until his contract is up.

Whats you smoking on?

The thing that I think is being overlooked here is that I called the Petry for Lindstrom trade the week before it happened, so I think that should carry a lot of weight when evaluating my ACGMs moving forward.

You also posted Matthew Tkachuk for Ben Chiarot, Raymond, Samson Pellikka, and a 1st. And Quinn Hughes + 2 1sts for 3 2nds.

If these players are worth what you're proposing, then the Wings are likely in solid playoff position, and then they wouldn't be having a fire-sale.

Until one of those players retire both proposals are still possible. Therefore my record remains untarnished. I'm batting 1000