Forums/GM Game 2018-19

2018-19 GM Game - Official Scoring Thread

Dec 3, 2018 at 11:21
#76
Thread Starter
Let'sGoBlues | WPGv4
Joined: Jun 2016
Posts: 4,259
Likes: 2,422


Jan 7 at 12:06
#77
Thread Starter
Let'sGoBlues | WPGv4
Joined: Jun 2016
Posts: 4,259
Likes: 2,422
Jan 7 at 12:07
#78
Thread Starter
Let'sGoBlues | WPGv4
Joined: Jun 2016
Posts: 4,259
Likes: 2,422


Feb 11 at 12:07
#79
Thread Starter
Let'sGoBlues | WPGv4
Joined: Jun 2016
Posts: 4,259
Likes: 2,422


Daryl liked this.
Mar 15 at 2:30
#80
Thread Starter
Let'sGoBlues | WPGv4
Joined: Jun 2016
Posts: 4,259
Likes: 2,422


Mar 15 at 2:35
#81
Thread Starter
Let'sGoBlues | WPGv4
Joined: Jun 2016
Posts: 4,259
Likes: 2,422
Attention GMs:

Normally, the cutoff for rosters is the 20th of each month. Considering the timing of the GM Game Trade Deadline, and the small number of remaining games in the IRL season, we have decided to date March roster acquisitions retroactively to the 1st of the month. This means that, unlike in other months, the players that you acquire after the 20th will count toward March scoring. Basically, your roster after the deadline will be pulled for scoring, not from the 20th.... now get out there and make some deadline moves.
l9guysports and Gronk liked this.
Apr 1 at 12:31
#82
Thread Starter
Let'sGoBlues | WPGv4
Joined: Jun 2016
Posts: 4,259
Likes: 2,422
@TonyStrecher @A_K @Bo53Horvat @BoltsPoint21 @krakowitz @l9guysports @TabooPenguo @phillyjabroni @Math @Rodzikhockey93 @Turner33 @ricochetii @HotsamBatcho @Luc3 @TMLSage @HallforHart @Missouri @Daryl @alwaysnextyear @rangersandislesfan @brenfox31 @flamesfan419 @Max @Icegirl @matt59 @NateElder12 @Gronk @jmac490 @Pross @mhockey91 @Mr_cap @MacWinnon

GMs:

if anyone would like to help with a dry run of playoff voting, please use this form to vote on our dummy series between #30 NJD and #31 NYR.

https://forms.gle/SkCxvGBeSGfRDMJF7

We plan to use the following general guidelines for voting.
- disregard the 0-10, just imagine a sliding scale that you are putting your vote where you think the advantage exists
- healthy rosters are assumed
- vote on every category
- puck luck and home-ice advantage are determined in the vote-tallying spreadsheet (I will release a populated example after we get some results from this test)
- GMs of teams involved in a series or implicated by owning the 2019 pick of either team involved in the vote will not be able to vote on those series (anyone can vote on this test though)

The form should require an email (might need a google account, not sure) so that only one submittal is allowed per person. Let me know in the general discussion thread if you have any feedback or if you run into any issues.

Thanks,
AK
rangersandislesfan, Bo53Horvat, alwaysnextyear and 3 others liked this.
Apr 5 at 11:01
#83
Thread Starter
Let'sGoBlues | WPGv4
Joined: Jun 2016
Posts: 4,259
Likes: 2,422
I don't think anyone actually looks at the inner workings of the scoring sheet but me - but if I'm wrong and people actually are looking at the background calculations, I have an update:

The score sheet does the arithmetic to subtract the YTD totals from the prior month from the YTD totals from the current month. From there, the monthly stats are looked up based on the team rosters (that change monthly). So for example, February stats are calculated as the stats thru Feb 28th minus the stats thru Jan 31st. However, since Corsica was down at the end of Februrary, Feb stats were collected from a variety of sources (and formatted to mirror the Corsica inputs so I didn't have to mess with the sheet).

When I pasted Corsica totals (site is up again) thru March into the sheet, I saw negative numbers on some counting stats during my QA... which is never good. This means that there was some disagreement between the running Corsica numbers and the numbers from Evolving-Hockey/OffsideReview. I spot checked a few players' stats, and I can't locate a simple correction to make. Since rosters change each month, I can't just take the sum of Feb and Mar stats and apply them to Mar rosters without there being a "loss of authenticity".

So, here is how I'm calculating Feb and Mar stats, since we don't have isolated Feb stats from Corsica (won't allow me to enter a date range to collect the data). The end-of-Jan stats will be subtracted from the end-of-season stats - all from Corsica. This will provide the stats for Feb+Mar (combined). From there, I will use half of the Feb+Mar totals as the Feb total to apply to Feb rosters (and in effect, the other half goes to Mar). It's not an exact replication of the season stats but it's the closest I can get without doing significantly more work. So you will see that Feb stats = Mar stats for each player, which isn't entirely accurate; but this will help account for players that changed teams between Feb and Mar.

Hopefully there is no confusion, or if there is, you'll just roll your eyes, mumble "this dude is a nerd" and move on with your real life. Nevertheless, you can DM me or @ me in the the discussion thread and I'll try to explain again wink.

p.s. I haven't published the final scoring/standings and won't do so until Monday, but I just wanted to share this in case someone opens up the sheet and sees the mess of formulas in the February data sheets.
Gronk, Daryl, l9guysports and 3 others liked this.
Apr 8 at 10:48
#84
Thread Starter
Let'sGoBlues | WPGv4
Joined: Jun 2016
Posts: 4,259
Likes: 2,422
Edited Apr 8 at 11:39. Reason: tweet removed
...
Apr 8 at 10:48
#85
Thread Starter
Let'sGoBlues | WPGv4
Joined: Jun 2016
Posts: 4,259
Likes: 2,422
Edited Apr 8 at 11:39. Reason: tweet removed
...
Apr 8 at 11:41
#86
Thread Starter
Let'sGoBlues | WPGv4
Joined: Jun 2016
Posts: 4,259
Likes: 2,422


Apr 10 at 11:50
#87
Thread Starter
Let'sGoBlues | WPGv4
Joined: Jun 2016
Posts: 4,259
Likes: 2,422
Edited Apr 10 at 11:55
@TonyStrecher @A_K @Bo53Horvat @BoltsPoint21 @krakowitz @l9guysports @TabooPenguo @phillyjabroni @Math @Rodzikhockey93 @Turner33 @ricochetii @HotsamBatcho @Luc3 @TMLSage @HallforHart @Missouri @Daryl @alwaysnextyear @rangersandislesfan @brenfox31 @flamesfan419 @Max @Icegirl @matt59 @NateElder12 @Gronk @jmac490 @Pross @mhockey91 @Mr_cap @MacWinnon

V3 PLAYOFFS

OK THIS IS AN ALL-CAPS POST BOYS AND GIRLS

TIME TO VOTE FOR YOUR ROUND 1 PLAYOFF WINNERS AND LOSERS

EACH GM CAN VOTE 1x ON EACH SERIES, UNLESS YOUR ARE THE GM OF A TEAM INVOLVED IN THE SERIES, OR IF YOU OWN A 2019 FIRST ROUND PICK OF EITHER TEAM INVOLVED IN THE SERIES. VOTING REQUIRES AN EMAIL AND ASKS FOR YOUR TEAM NAME, SO WE WILL BE CHECKING FOR COMPLIANCE WITH THIS RULE AS WE TALLY THE VOTES. CHEATING WILL BE DETECTED AND WILL VOID ALL OF THE VOTES THAT THE GUILTY PARTY TRIES TO PLACE ON ALL SERIES, SO PLEASE DON'T WASTE OUR TIME (OR YOURS).

EACH POLL SHOWS TEAM ROSTERS, REGULAR SEASON RANKINGS IN EACH SCORING CATEGORY (1 IS BEST, 31 IS WORST), AND WHAT I CALL "GOLF SCORE", WHICH IS THE OVERALL SUM OF THE CATEGORICAL RANKINGS (LIKE IN GOLF, LOW SCORE IS BETTER). IF YOU HAVE TROUBLE SEEING THE PICTURE IN THE POLL, EACH MATCHUP HAS A TAB IN THE SCORING SHEET (https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/11kF_rV7vT8q2KNcwX3ClKLzQaQ_Mz9igZUNyAhbkT4w/edit?usp=sharing)

LUCK AND HOME-ICE ARE ACCOUNTED FOR AFTER WE TALLY THE VOTES, SO PLEASE ONLY ACCOUNT FOR THE ROSTER QUALITY WHEN YOU CAST YOUR VOTES. ROSTERS ARE SHOWN AT THE TOP OF EACH POLL.

ONCE SUBMITTED, VOTES CAN NOT BE CHANGED. IF YOU MADE A MISTAKE, NOTIFY ME. IF YOU CHANGE YOUR MIND, DON'T NOTIFY ME, YOUR FIRST SUBMITTAL IS FINAL. SO IF YOU HAVE ANY QUESTIONS ABOUT HOW TO VOTE, CONTACT ME BEFORE YOU SUBMIT YOUR VOTES!

VOTING WILL CLOSE AT MIDNIGHT EASTERN ON WEDNESDAY APRIL 17TH, 2019.

ROUND 1:

#1 STL VS #8 WPG https://forms.gle/PWN5pqVDGu8vdtmw6

#4 DAL VS #5 EDM https://forms.gle/mxX19w1uQVfYjnCt7

#3 VGK VS #6 MIN https://forms.gle/JCRo3gUhE8FcayLc7

#2 VAN VS #7 NSH https://forms.gle/iiFePc6UxZcWnwNv5
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
#1 CBJ VS #8 WSH https://forms.gle/GD2aDjX2i47AeFyS6

#4 BOS VS #5 NYI https://forms.gle/qp4RDqh2xodRGSqm8

#3 TOR VS #6 CAR https://forms.gle/TirMJ4E9yfpG57gH8

#2 PHI VS #7 PIT https://forms.gle/bRzNpgrMvtdxTPQW7
ricochetii, flamesfan419, l9guysports and 7 others liked this.
Apr 15 at 10:28
#88
Joined: Mar 2017
Posts: 5,986
Likes: 1,064
Quoting: A_K
@TonyStrecher @A_K @Bo53Horvat @BoltsPoint21 @krakowitz @l9guysports @TabooPenguo @phillyjabroni @Math @Rodzikhockey93 @Turner33 @ricochetii @HotsamBatcho @Luc3 @TMLSage @HallforHart @Missouri @Daryl @alwaysnextyear @rangersandislesfan @brenfox31 @flamesfan419 @Max @Icegirl @matt59 @NateElder12 @Gronk @jmac490 @Pross @mhockey91 @Mr_cap @MacWinnon

V3 PLAYOFFS

OK THIS IS AN ALL-CAPS POST BOYS AND GIRLS

TIME TO VOTE FOR YOUR ROUND 1 PLAYOFF WINNERS AND LOSERS

EACH GM CAN VOTE 1x ON EACH SERIES, UNLESS YOUR ARE THE GM OF A TEAM INVOLVED IN THE SERIES, OR IF YOU OWN A 2019 FIRST ROUND PICK OF EITHER TEAM INVOLVED IN THE SERIES. VOTING REQUIRES AN EMAIL AND ASKS FOR YOUR TEAM NAME, SO WE WILL BE CHECKING FOR COMPLIANCE WITH THIS RULE AS WE TALLY THE VOTES. CHEATING WILL BE DETECTED AND WILL VOID ALL OF THE VOTES THAT THE GUILTY PARTY TRIES TO PLACE ON ALL SERIES, SO PLEASE DON'T WASTE OUR TIME (OR YOURS).

EACH POLL SHOWS TEAM ROSTERS, REGULAR SEASON RANKINGS IN EACH SCORING CATEGORY (1 IS BEST, 31 IS WORST), AND WHAT I CALL "GOLF SCORE", WHICH IS THE OVERALL SUM OF THE CATEGORICAL RANKINGS (LIKE IN GOLF, LOW SCORE IS BETTER). IF YOU HAVE TROUBLE SEEING THE PICTURE IN THE POLL, EACH MATCHUP HAS A TAB IN THE SCORING SHEET (https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/11kF_rV7vT8q2KNcwX3ClKLzQaQ_Mz9igZUNyAhbkT4w/edit?usp=sharing)

LUCK AND HOME-ICE ARE ACCOUNTED FOR AFTER WE TALLY THE VOTES, SO PLEASE ONLY ACCOUNT FOR THE ROSTER QUALITY WHEN YOU CAST YOUR VOTES. ROSTERS ARE SHOWN AT THE TOP OF EACH POLL.

ONCE SUBMITTED, VOTES CAN NOT BE CHANGED. IF YOU MADE A MISTAKE, NOTIFY ME. IF YOU CHANGE YOUR MIND, DON'T NOTIFY ME, YOUR FIRST SUBMITTAL IS FINAL. SO IF YOU HAVE ANY QUESTIONS ABOUT HOW TO VOTE, CONTACT ME BEFORE YOU SUBMIT YOUR VOTES!

VOTING WILL CLOSE AT MIDNIGHT EASTERN ON WEDNESDAY APRIL 17TH, 2019.

ROUND 1:

#1 STL VS #8 WPG https://forms.gle/PWN5pqVDGu8vdtmw6

#4 DAL VS #5 EDM https://forms.gle/mxX19w1uQVfYjnCt7

#3 VGK VS #6 MIN https://forms.gle/JCRo3gUhE8FcayLc7

#2 VAN VS #7 NSH https://forms.gle/iiFePc6UxZcWnwNv5
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
#1 CBJ VS #8 WSH https://forms.gle/GD2aDjX2i47AeFyS6

#4 BOS VS #5 NYI https://forms.gle/qp4RDqh2xodRGSqm8

#3 TOR VS #6 CAR https://forms.gle/TirMJ4E9yfpG57gH8

#2 PHI VS #7 PIT https://forms.gle/bRzNpgrMvtdxTPQW7


Wait why the F isn't Dumba on my roster? Mr. K, just because I refused to pay you.......
Apr 16 at 12:35
#89
Thread Starter
Let'sGoBlues | WPGv4
Joined: Jun 2016
Posts: 4,259
Likes: 2,422
Quoting: Turner33
Wait why the F isn't Dumba on my roster? Mr. K, just because I refused to pay you.......


Players with season-ending/long-term injuries were left off of playoff rosters Confused
Apr 16 at 1:37
#90
Joined: Mar 2017
Posts: 5,986
Likes: 1,064
Quoting: A_K
Players with season-ending/long-term injuries were left off of playoff rosters Confused


He was set to come back if they made the playoffs. U guys said it was assumed health in the playoffs
Apr 16 at 9:33
#91
Thread Starter
Let'sGoBlues | WPGv4
Joined: Jun 2016
Posts: 4,259
Likes: 2,422
Quoting: Turner33
He was set to come back if they made the playoffs. U guys said it was assumed health in the playoffs


I saw a note that he was going to be 100% for camp - that made it sound like he was still recovering. But if you say he's healthy, I can put him back on your roster.
Apr 16 at 9:57
#92
Joined: Mar 2017
Posts: 5,986
Likes: 1,064
Quoting: A_K
I saw a note that he was going to be 100% for camp - that made it sound like he was still recovering. But if you say he's healthy, I can put him back on your roster.


His timetable was right to the ends of the season. I always read, he should be available by the playoffs. But then the gm actively tried to miss, so I'm sure he didn't want to risk him playing at all.
A_K liked this.
Apr 16 at 10:53
#93
Thread Starter
Let'sGoBlues | WPGv4
Joined: Jun 2016
Posts: 4,259
Likes: 2,422
Quoting: Turner33
His timetable was right to the ends of the season. I always read, he should be available by the playoffs. But then the gm actively tried to miss, so I'm sure he didn't want to risk him playing at all.


To summarize: the Wild suck, Dumba might be healthy, Dumba has been put back on your roster, sorry for the mishap, Wild suck.
Max, Turner33 and Icegirl liked this.
Apr 16 at 2:30
#94
Joined: Mar 2017
Posts: 5,986
Likes: 1,064
Quoting: A_K
To summarize: the Wild suck, Dumba might be healthy, Dumba has been put back on your roster, sorry for the mishap, Wild suck.


[Insert nodding snoop dog gif]
Apr 17 at 12:57
#95
Oui non grille-pain
Joined: Feb 2017
Posts: 5,790
Likes: 1,216
Quoting: A_K
To summarize: the Wild suck, Dumba might be healthy, Dumba has been put back on your roster, sorry for the mishap, Wild suck.


I know. You don't need to rub it in Sticking Out Tongue
Turner33 liked this.
Apr 17 at 11:29
#96
NateElder12
Joined: Apr 2016
Posts: 5,736
Likes: 799
Quoting: Turner33
His timetable was right to the ends of the season. I always read, he should be available by the playoffs. But then the gm actively tried to miss, so I'm sure he didn't want to risk him playing at all.


same with Kase then too.. and add McDavid to my team while you're at it
Apr 17 at 11:49
#97
Joined: Mar 2017
Posts: 5,986
Likes: 1,064
Quoting: NateElder12
same with Kase then too.. and add McDavid to my team while you're at it


Dumba is expected to be out until late March with an injury that stems from his fight against Matthew Tkachuk in a Dec. 15 game

-CBS sport
Apr 17 at 12:16
#98
NateElder12
Joined: Apr 2016
Posts: 5,736
Likes: 799
Quoting: Turner33
Dumba is expected to be out until late March with an injury that stems from his fight against Matthew Tkachuk in a Dec. 15 game

-CBS sport


CBS... never heard of them
Turner33 liked this.
Apr 17 at 12:49
#99
Thread Starter
Let'sGoBlues | WPGv4
Joined: Jun 2016
Posts: 4,259
Likes: 2,422
Edited Apr 17 at 1:04
@TonyStrecher @A_K @Bo53Horvat @BoltsPoint21 @krakowitz @l9guysports @TabooPenguo @phillyjabroni @Math @Rodzikhockey93 @Turner33 @ricochetii @HotsamBatcho @Luc3 @TMLSage @HallforHart @Missouri @Daryl @alwaysnextyear @rangersandislesfan @brenfox31 @flamesfan419 @Max @Icegirl @matt59 @NateElder12 @Gronk @jmac490 @Pross @mhockey91 @Mr_cap @MacWinnon

Ok GM's... here's how the playoff vote tallying is gonna go down.

- GM voting establishes raw score (i.e. 50 pts possible in each series; 25-25 would be a dead tie)
- 1 pt is added to the home team's score for each game (7 games simulated, 2-2-1-1-1)
- luck is a split of 8 points, distributed randomly in each game (7 games simulated)
- each of the 7 games simulated has a winner and loser, the team with 4+ wins in the simulation that I press 'go' for is the winner of the series

I'll publish the results as a 4-X result with a little blurb about each one, and then later on i'll publish the scoring sheets (they'll show the results of the 7-game sim and the win% probability of the home team based on 924 simulations)

why 924? that's where my sheet ended smile
NateElder12, Pross, Gronk and 5 others liked this.
Apr 22 at 10:14
#100
Thread Starter
Let'sGoBlues | WPGv4
Joined: Jun 2016
Posts: 4,259
Likes: 2,422
Reminder: Round 2 voting is underway and will be open until Wednesday the 24th (midnight ET). If you own a 2019 first round pick that belongs to either team involved in a matchup, you cannot vote in that matchup. And you cannot vote in your own matchup.

Round 2:

#1 STL vs #4 DAL https://forms.gle/XeFhLZD2VvRSztRF6

#2 VAN vs #3 VGK https://forms.gle/zWdN8wSz9qxmMekp7

#4 BOS vs #8 WSH https://forms.gle/odFrVYz2ekiGvcAj8

#2 PHI vs #3 TOR https://forms.gle/Zzpnbx66uv8WnNtZ7
PattyMack88 liked this.
 
Reply
To create a post please Login or Register
Question:
Options:
Add Option
Remove Option
Submit Poll