Quoting: KSIxSKULLS
That's crazy if it's true. I'd say he's more comparable with Gretzky/Lemieux type of players. The numbers he's putting up are historic.
Quoting: KSIxSKULLS
Bedard has done everything at a higher level than McDavid did. That's why I'm saying his comparable is higher.
Quoting: aadoyle
Now your just being silly
How do we not know Bedard comes into the league and does better than McDavid. We dont
Bedard might come in and be avg or come in and shock the world doing things even McDavid hasnt done. Heck maybe he basically does the same numbers first 5 years and by year 8 has 700 points to lul
Might not be immediate but saying nobody will be like McDavid or get on his level is silly as there will always come a better prospect with time thats how hockey works
Will it be Bedard or someone in the next 10 years idk but hes got all the time in the world to do his thing
For the sake of my own curiosity, I used NHLe to backwards-translate Matthews' stats had he actually played for Everett instead of sticking with the USDP and buggering off to Zurich. His 15- through 18-year old seasons are as such:
67GP: 16.879 G / 13.810 A / 30.689 P
67GP: 32.233 G / 33.975 A / 66.208 P
62GP: 49.808 G / 60.231 A / 110.039 P
57GP: 61.851 G / 56.697 A / 118.548 P
It's really hard to correlate what Bedard's 2020-21 WHL season should have looked like because the WHL played divisions-only that season and Bedard did not have access to any of the better WHL competition that season. What I do notice however is that Matthews has the better D-1 season while Bedard is projected to have the better D0 season. I very much think that has everything to do with the linemate quality Matthews had in the NLA and that his supposed Everett production probably outpaces what Bedard is doing this year if we consider season-over-season growth. Even this mathematical experiment shows that in his D-1 season, Matthews would have outproduced McDavid by about half a point. There was a lot of hype going into the 2016 Draft that Matthews was at worst on par with McDavid. The year-over-year separation shows us otherwise.
Regardless, the trajectory that we do have suggests that Bedard is projecting slightly below Matthews territory right now if we make the allowance for Auston's NLA numbers negatively skewing his D0 season. Bedard's current projection has him finishing about 1.8 points behind McDavid in his draft year. It's rarified territory regardless of where he lands. Do I think he could break the modern WHL record? I hope he does. I do wonder if his skillset and size are going to translate as well as Matthews' allowed him into the NHL. Bedard might be quicker and shiftier than Matthews which should help him adjust until he hits another growth spurt.
There are a lot of plus shooters and plus-plus shooters in the NHL right now. But nobody speaks of the likes of Laine or Pastrnak in the same postal code as McDavid. Matthews gets that attention due to his positioning and where he was drafted and until we're shown otherwise, I still think that the Auston Matthews comparable is more appropriate. McDavid's hockey IQ is probably second to only Gretzky and he combines that with skill and the kind of speed never before seen in the NHL.