Emotionally in 2018
Joined: Nov. 2016
Posts: 9,293
Likes: 3,387
For me, it's Kevin Shattenkirk. Not just because of how much of a disappointment he was in the playoffs for the Caps last season, but because of the sheer number of turnovers and silly giveaways that he makes. I've seen a lot of it now that he's with the Rangers too, not just with his short time with the Caps. I'm not sure if this was an issue in St. Louis, but it certainly has been one now.
Quick side note // I feel like everybody has answered Jonathan Toews for this question so many times that he isn't really overrated anymore (except by media).